View Full Version : Would you watch professional boxing if the fighters wore headgear?


Mr. Untouchable
12-08-2004, 12:33 PM
I just read this story on *********.com...
Colombian bantamweight prospect Carlos Meza passed away Tuesday afternoon at the Santo Tomas Hospital in Panama City, Panama. Meza suffered a cerebral hematoma and massive hemorrhage, cerebral hernia and edema, after being knocked out by world ranked Panamanian Ricardo Cordoba on Friday night in Colon City, Panama. The previously undefeated Meza (8-0, 7 KOs) put Cordoba down in round four of their Fedelatin fight, then traded punches with "El Maestrito" until the 12th and final round when a powerful combination sent him to the canvas and later to the nearest hospital. Meza's condition worsened yesterday as he was declared brain dead and went into an irreversible coma. "Sadly, Meza passed away," confirmed Panama Boxing Commission president Miguel Prado. Meza would have turned 27 on December 24.
Would you watch boxing if they wore modified headgear. Nothing protecting the face or chin, just something to cushion the blows to the head???

SacTown1
12-08-2004, 01:30 PM
Boxing isn't a soft sport, it's the most physically intense competition on the planet, these guys get paid millions to get knocked in the head, possible fatalities are a part of what comes with those millions, these guys choose to box, nobody forces them to do it, so if they can't take the heat then they gotta get their a$$ outta the kitchen. I don't see Ali or Frazier complaining about their post-boxing injuries. Those injuries made them LEGENDS. Would we be kissing the ground Ali walks on if he were still speaking fluently? HECK NO, we'd be criticizing him for being a selfish egotistical maniac. But now that he's got pugilistic dimentia (on top of Parkinson's), he's a world-renowned hero. And it's because of his injuries, and what he sacrificed in the ring, and his current condition, that has made him a legend. So to answer your question, if pro boxers wore headgear, we wouldn't have legends to look up to. YOUR THOUGHTS!!! - SacTown1

abdiel2k3
12-08-2004, 01:37 PM
I just read this story on *********.com...
Colombian bantamweight prospect Carlos Meza passed away Tuesday afternoon at the Santo Tomas Hospital in Panama City, Panama. Meza suffered a cerebral hematoma and massive hemorrhage, cerebral hernia and edema, after being knocked out by world ranked Panamanian Ricardo Cordoba on Friday night in Colon City, Panama. The previously undefeated Meza (8-0, 7 KOs) put Cordoba down in round four of their Fedelatin fight, then traded punches with "El Maestrito" until the 12th and final round when a powerful combination sent him to the canvas and later to the nearest hospital. Meza's condition worsened yesterday as he was declared brain dead and went into an irreversible coma. "Sadly, Meza passed away," confirmed Panama Boxing Commission president Miguel Prado. Meza would have turned 27 on December 24.
Would you watch boxing if they wore modified headgear. Nothing protecting the face or chin, just something to cushion the blows to the head???

prolly only when i knew a devestaing body puncher was goin to be fightin
it would really take away from the thrill of them layin their lives on the line
not to say it makes them 100%safe
but it def adds a bit of pussieness to the sport
specially in da pros

Mr. Untouchable
12-08-2004, 03:15 PM
Boxing isn't a soft sport, it's the most physically intense competition on the planet, these guys get paid millions to get knocked in the head, possible fatalities are a part of what comes with those millions, these guys choose to box, nobody forces them to do it, so if they can't take the heat then they gotta get their a$$ outta the kitchen. I don't see Ali or Frazier complaining about their post-boxing injuries. Those injuries made them LEGENDS. Would we be kissing the ground Ali walks on if he were still speaking fluently? HECK NO, we'd be criticizing him for being a selfish egotistical maniac. But now that he's got pugilistic dimentia (on top of Parkinson's), he's a world-renowned hero. And it's because of his injuries, and what he sacrificed in the ring, and his current condition, that has made him a legend. So to answer your question, if pro boxers wore headgear, we wouldn't have legends to look up to. YOUR THOUGHTS!!! - SacTown1I love the sport of boxing and I love seeing people get knocked out, but I really thought roy jones was dead when he got hit in the head. I fell like bust a mutha****as body and face up all day but the blows to the head seem a little crazy if it weren't for the gloves no one would even get hit in the head...to go along with what you said why don't they just take the gloves off to and make it a real blood sport?? I really don't have a comeback to what you have written, you summed it up pretty well, but I would like to add that all boxers don't get paid millions. The guy that just died was a 8 an 0 contender so I am pretty sure he died for a few grand...

Mr. Untouchable
12-08-2004, 03:16 PM
Boxing isn't a soft sport, it's the most physically intense competition on the planet, these guys get paid millions to get knocked in the head, possible fatalities are a part of what comes with those millions, these guys choose to box, nobody forces them to do it, so if they can't take the heat then they gotta get their a$$ outta the kitchen. I don't see Ali or Frazier complaining about their post-boxing injuries. Those injuries made them LEGENDS. Would we be kissing the ground Ali walks on if he were still speaking fluently? HECK NO, we'd be criticizing him for being a selfish egotistical maniac. But now that he's got pugilistic dimentia (on top of Parkinson's), he's a world-renowned hero. And it's because of his injuries, and what he sacrificed in the ring, and his current condition, that has made him a legend. So to answer your question, if pro boxers wore headgear, we wouldn't have legends to look up to. YOUR THOUGHTS!!! - SacTown1I have a question for you? would you still have the same opinion if you see your favorite fighter dead from a blow to the head?

tracylee
12-08-2004, 03:20 PM
I just read this story on *********.com...
Colombian bantamweight prospect Carlos Meza passed away Tuesday afternoon at the Santo Tomas Hospital in Panama City, Panama. Meza suffered a cerebral hematoma and massive hemorrhage, cerebral hernia and edema, after being knocked out by world ranked Panamanian Ricardo Cordoba on Friday night in Colon City, Panama. The previously undefeated Meza (8-0, 7 KOs) put Cordoba down in round four of their Fedelatin fight, then traded punches with "El Maestrito" until the 12th and final round when a powerful combination sent him to the canvas and later to the nearest hospital. Meza's condition worsened yesterday as he was declared brain dead and went into an irreversible coma. "Sadly, Meza passed away," confirmed Panama Boxing Commission president Miguel Prado. Meza would have turned 27 on December 24.
Would you watch boxing if they wore modified headgear. Nothing protecting the face or chin, just something to cushion the blows to the head???

Probably...I love the sport THAT much! I wouldnt be too thrilled about it, but if that were the only option, then yeah I would

n14061981
12-08-2004, 03:39 PM
Terrible news. Sometimes incidents like this keep me away from following boxing for a while. I always come back though...

SacTown1
12-08-2004, 04:00 PM
Gerald McClellan was one of my favorite fighters, and I've got all of the respect in the world for him and his abilities in the ring, and when Nigel Benn put him in a coma with excessive rabbit punching, I didn't blame Benn for one second, nor did I lose interest in the sport. It's a blood sport, you're absolutely right. But Gerald is where he is today because he did what he loved doing, which was boxing against the best competition in the world. So yes, I still love the KO, I love seeing guys get "stretched" as Prince Naseem used to say, and if there are fatalities along the way, so be it. Kids get killed every day crossing the street, does that mean we shouldn't give them shoes or let them go outside?

Mr. Untouchable
12-08-2004, 04:11 PM
Gerald McClellan was one of my favorite fighters, and I've got all of the respect in the world for him and his abilities in the ring, and when Nigel Benn put him in a coma with excessive rabbit punching, I didn't blame Benn for one second, nor did I lose interest in the sport. It's a blood sport, you're absolutely right. But Gerald is where he is today because he did what he loved doing, which was boxing against the best competition in the world. So yes, I still love the KO, I love seeing guys get "stretched" as Prince Naseem used to say, and if there are fatalities along the way, so be it. Kids get killed every day crossing the street, does that mean we shouldn't give them shoes or let them go outside?Good point!!

Ivansmamma
12-08-2004, 04:27 PM
I don't think i would whatch boxing if the fighters wore headgear, i don't like the new olympic gloves which twists the hands so it's harder to get a knockout either. Boxing shouldn't be changed to becme softer, then it wouldn't be boxing.

leff
12-08-2004, 05:17 PM
It would lose some off the charm but, id still watch it

Atwa_66
12-08-2004, 05:30 PM
It would be weird, but I would watch it still, It does take away part of the sport, but i wouldn't stop watching. That is very sad that a fighter died like that. :(

Brotherfromthehoods
12-08-2004, 07:11 PM
i think thats y people watch boxing, if people wanna watch a soft sport, they'd watch karate.

simeraksou
12-08-2004, 07:37 PM
I just read this story on *********.com...
Colombian bantamweight prospect Carlos Meza passed away Tuesday afternoon at the Santo Tomas Hospital in Panama City, Panama. Meza suffered a cerebral hematoma and massive hemorrhage, cerebral hernia and edema, after being knocked out by world ranked Panamanian Ricardo Cordoba on Friday night in Colon City, Panama. The previously undefeated Meza (8-0, 7 KOs) put Cordoba down in round four of their Fedelatin fight, then traded punches with "El Maestrito" until the 12th and final round when a powerful combination sent him to the canvas and later to the nearest hospital. Meza's condition worsened yesterday as he was declared brain dead and went into an irreversible coma. "Sadly, Meza passed away," confirmed Panama Boxing Commission president Miguel Prado. Meza would have turned 27 on December 24.
Would you watch boxing if they wore modified headgear. Nothing protecting the face or chin, just something to cushion the blows to the head???
I would watch boxing if they had headgear. I dont' watch boxing just for the knockouts, I wanna see the skills too. I agree that they should have a modified headgear that surrounds just the head. This also helps protect their head from the canvass if they get knocked down.

lapulapu
12-08-2004, 09:53 PM
I don't think i would whatch boxing if the fighters wore headgear, i don't like the new olympic gloves which twists the hands so it's harder to get a knockout either. Boxing shouldn't be changed to becme softer, then it wouldn't be boxing.

Some guys don't belong in boxing. If boxing is such a danger then only those who can take it should become boxers.
I agree with the comments above.

IwatchBoxing
12-08-2004, 11:50 PM
I'd probaly watch it every once in awhile but I'd probaly wouldnt....

Hunna
12-10-2004, 02:15 AM
Sad to hear about the fatal bout. Boxing fans for a longtime are used to proboxers without headgear, thats what seperate pros from amateurs.
Also, seeing the fighters face, adds more effect to the attraction.
Like, who would know what Mike tyson really looked like, if he wore headgear all his life.

dingus
12-10-2004, 02:37 AM
IF (I would hate to see this rule as it may only damage the sport)headgear did come into regulation for boxers, I think it should only be worn by boxers with 10 or less pro fights or possibly those ranked 20 or less. I know boxers can die no matter what the situation, but to if(and I mean only if) headgear were to be a rule, I think top twenty ranked boxers or those with over 10 pro fights should be exempt due to their experience. I believe in no way should a title fight or even a fight between two top ten contenders take place with the fighters wearing headgear. The fighters SHOULD(and I emphasize SHOULD because there is always possiblility of a death in the ring) have the experience to not(as should the refs to not allow a fighter)get beaten unmercifully.

dumb donnie
06-05-2005, 10:58 AM
Well, I would probably still watch it, but I don't think it would really be boxing anymore. Perhaps if it was given a different name so it would be clear that it is separate from boxing. The headgear just takes away from the prestige, it's just not the same.

Hunna
06-06-2005, 12:10 AM
silly question really? would u watch PPV fighters in headgear?.... i dont think so

Kid Achilles
06-06-2005, 12:22 AM
The question is moot because headgear doesn't prevent concussions and therefore is not an effective safeguard against brain damage or death. A concussion occurs when your head is jarred back from the force of a blow, causing your brain to shift within your skull. Repeated concussions are what cause brain damage and most deaths in boxing.

A layer of padding around your head and chin does not protect your head from being snapped back; it just shields you from getting cut.

If you wanted to really cut down on brain damage and death in boxing, you'd need to completeley illegalize headshots.

solo1bc
06-07-2005, 04:15 AM
I'd watch it if I had no other choice but I wouldn't like it..

jchavez12345
06-07-2005, 11:33 AM
i dont think i would watch, there is always a risk associated with boxing and thats why people get paid as much as they do, if not more people would do it.

sanjayint
06-07-2005, 02:14 PM
forget, conccussionz, its all about hate!! u fight bcoz you have a hate, i hate it when boxers have great respect for each other, its dog eat dog out there!!

MAXWELL_
06-07-2005, 05:26 PM
i can think of many fights where the outcome may have been different if they wore headgear.

hell yes i'd watch pro's fight if they wore headgear.

scottie
06-07-2005, 09:16 PM
id watch too just like in the amateurs. but it wont be as exciting

Sir Fancylot
06-08-2005, 04:32 AM
forget, conccussionz, its all about hate!! u fight bcoz you have a hate, i hate it when boxers have great respect for each other, its dog eat dog out there!!

I hope you're joking.

otherwise you're a neanderthal.

roberson2u
06-10-2005, 02:17 AM
naw...leave head gear to the amateurs

Martin (Top Knowledge)
06-10-2005, 07:05 AM
I'd still watch it because I like the movement, :rolleyes: It's like watching poetry... LOL!...

But I like to be able to see the expressions on fighters faces, You can see more easily when someone's getting the better of their opponent. (Like when a fighter doesn't wanna be in there).

Head guards take that away.

tony22
06-10-2005, 08:34 AM
Yes I would still watch it.