From the get go I thought Mitchell may have bitten off more than he can chew with Katsidis. I thought Mitchell could win but would have to go to hell and back. When I saw the two of them in the ring Katsidis looked a LOT bigger. He looks like he could make LWW easy. Mitchell has to be given a LOT of credit just for taking this dangerous fight. This was not Khan Kotelnik where the Warren fighter had been set up with a soft touch for title level fighter. Mitchell lost and I have seen lots of Khan supporters make negitive comments about him losing. I would like to point out that Khan has not faced a single fighter at Katsidis level.

If Khan were to fight Katsidis who do you think would win?

If the bum Prescott can beat him I'm positive Katsidis can. Katsidis is very underrated imo.

When you have freddy roach in your corner, I would favour Khan. Khan is a better fighter than Mitchell all day. It would be one hell of a fight, though.

Khan is trully a lot better than Mitchell, he's physically bigger than katsidis, a LOT quicker than mitchell and hits harder, however chinny chin chin so i think katsidis gets him eventually unless kahn manages to blast him

khan beats him badly

Khan ahs more skill but to be honest, we've neevr seen him in there is a good fighters, not a great fighter, just a good one. Kotelnik and the Barrera he fought dont count as good fighters. Because we've never seen him in with a fighter as good as Katsidis is, I would give Katsidis the edge. We just dont know how Khan would be able to handle Katsidis' pressure. We dont know if he has the mental strength to stick to his game plan under pressure, so its hard to say how he could win this fight

Until Khan shows me more, Katsidis, either by decision or KO, depending on how Khan's chin holds up.

From the get go I thought Mitchell may have bitten off more than he can chew with Katsidis. I thought Mitchell could win but would have to go to hell and back. When I saw the two of them in the ring Katsidis looked a LOT bigger. He looks like he could make LWW easy. Mitchell has to be given a LOT of credit just for taking this dangerous fight. This was not Khan Kotelnik where the Warren fighter had been set up with a soft touch for title level fighter. Mitchell lost and I have seen lots of Khan supporters make negitive comments about him losing. I would like to point out that Khan has not faced a single fighter at Katsidis level.

If Khan were to fight Katsidis who do you think would win?

its obvs people are going to vote Katsidis after he just beated Mitchell...

its obvs people are going to vote Katsidis after he just beated Mitchell...

The Poll right now is 6 Khan 4 Katsidis.

The Poll right now is 6 Khan 4 Katsidis.

oh no im not hating etc i watch amir khan and i like him and have been watching him since 2005 and all im just saying since katsidis won he will be getting hyped abit now and more people are going to vote for him

Katsidis has great strength, but i dont think hes good enough to beat Khan. I'm guted about Mitchell :sad:

Of course though if khan does fight him, people will say he cherry picked a ''blown up lightweight'' or that kats was a punching bag so fight proves nothing. Its maidana we want, hopefully kellerman presses khan in the post fight interview and goldenboy say yes

i feel bad mitchel lost..but my family overated him when he beat prescott.....now i can say i told you soooo....i knew this would happen

I like Khan but something tells me this match up is all wrong for him. Kats by KO.

i agree Kat is under rated it would be interesting to see if khan could take his shots

I think Khan doesnt like fighting on the inside. He could get bullied to the ropes like Mitchel was and possibly KO'd.

Yet Khan being bigger, faster and dangerous at range, he would land those big lefts and rights.

Would be a good fight.

I'd love to say Khan, but if I use my head then I think Katsidis would stop him quite early on.

Amir Khan.

I would pick Khan to beat Katsidis on points. But you never know with Amir's suspect chin?

khan by TKO

Khan out boxes him and wins.....Katsidas is WAY too aggresive for his own good and would just run at Khan and Khan would move and box

Katsidas does have a punchers chance tho

the katman

Katsidis is a powerful pressure fighter at top level! The only one of them khans beaten is barrera, who was hopelessly out of his weight division and past his best. koltnek and mallignaggi are good fighters. Tho non punchers and not of the style that beats khan. He has a good chance with roach, but i cant help thinking Katdidis wins by KO!!!

katsidis fought the best in his division...i think experience will give katsidis an edge in this fight..add khan's chin..he will win by stoppage..

I think that Khan could stop Katsidis. Maybe 8th or 9th round TKO if he catches Katsidis flush and uncorks a huge combination which he has been known to do. I don't know if Katsidis can weather the storm to get inside and hurt Khan.

Close fight i think. Hard to call. Katsidis could catch Khan and win by KO. Bit theres a chance Khan will stop Katsidis when he comes steaming in.
Khans a physically big, and also has the ability to out-box Katsidis. Id go with Khan on points, he would have to work hard to stay away from a big Katsidis shot though.

either UD for Khan or KO for Katsidis; Khan can box and is improving but Katsidis is no mug and can bang; half a Katsidis shot is enough to take Khan out...

That Aussie fella would win.

Katsidis inside the distance.

I don't want to see it. :sad1:

Khan UD.

I don't want to see it. :sad1:

Khan UD.


What?????

Really bro? Your like the biggest Kats fan on the scene. You really think he would lose?

What?????

Really bro? Your like the biggest Kats fan on the scene. You really think he would lose?

Yup. I'm what one would call an objective fan - I think realistically with my brain, not with my heart.

Despite all the attacking pressure Kats would bring to the fight, Khan being 3 inches taller than him with that huge range of his would dictate the action. He'd just keep him at the end of his jab and fire off lightning fast combos to discourage Kats from attacking so much.

Then, as soon they get back to fighting in the middle of the ring, Khan would tee off on him and maybe even stop him. If Kats can survive the bombs, then he'd only lose via UD.

All in all, Khan has too much power and speed. Kats would only have a puncher's chance, and even then we don't know if Khan's chin at 140 is as bad as everyone says it is (he only suffered KDs at 135).

Katdidis wins by KO .....

No way would Katsidis win by KO.

Khan isn't the biggest puncher but he's physically stronger than Mitchel. Kat won't be able to walk through Khan's punches.

and if Khan gets rocked he's strong enough to hold on

From the get go I thought Mitchell may have bitten off more than he can chew with Katsidis. I thought Mitchell could win but would have to go to hell and back. When I saw the two of them in the ring Katsidis looked a LOT bigger. He looks like he could make LWW easy. Mitchell has to be given a LOT of credit just for taking this dangerous fight. This was not Khan Kotelnik where the Warren fighter had been set up with a soft touch for title level fighter. Mitchell lost and I have seen lots of Khan supporters make negitive comments about him losing. I would like to point out that Khan has not faced a single fighter at Katsidis level.

If Khan were to fight Katsidis who do you think would win?

Liar :nonono:. We didnt say sh*t. Mitchell is a nobody.

Mitchell is a nobody.

The same nobody who trounced the nobody who KO'ed your boy?

Yeah, way to discredit 3 guys with one word. Think before you type.

The same nobody who trounced the nobody who KO'ed your boy?

Yeah, way to discredit 3 guys with one word. Think before you type.

Yes. Amir got KO'd by a nobody.

Youre missing the point though. John Hue claims that we Khan fans were slating Mitchell because he lost. IMO we should have slated him because he talked trash about Amir but we didnt because Mitchell isnt worth mentioning. Thats why I called him a nobody.

Very easy to slate Mitchell after he got beat by Katsidis who is a very good fighter ....but the joke is Khan got absolutely starched by a bum that Mitchell owned ! !
I like Khan but wanna see how he deals with a big puncher...if he deals with someone like Katsidis easy then i will be more inclined to jump on his band wagon :boxing:

yall are reallly realllllly reallllllly trippin if yall think this journey "like gatti" men can beat khan....ahaha dude khan will BLOW this clown outta the water...kat will be lucky to land one good shot. In fact this fight doesnt go the distance. Watch kids and learn.

I think Khan would box his way to a decision. The chin is always an issue but he keeps his hands up now and has excellent skills. Mitchell was a Warren hype job of the lowest order. I saw him live at Wembley and despite stopping the Colombian bum in 2 rounds, I wasn't fooled a single bit. He didn't have the power or strength to deter a fighter like Katsidis or any decent lightweight for that matter. Murray would beat him.

I was at the Mitchell vs Katsidis fight. Mitchell seemed detemined to test Katsidis power which surprised me. He looked like his ego got the better of him which I dont understand as with Prescott he boxed beautifully.

Mitchell was catching Katsidis and stunned him a couple of times when Mitchell took the center of the ring. When he just stood on the ropes and traded he looked very vunerable, he had a philly shell guard similar to Mayweather but didnt use it very well in this position as he was hurt badly a few times.

I think Khan would keep the center of the ring, he knows from experience not to fight a puncher at their own game and he would box Katsidis and use his speed to beat him up and win a lopsided points decision or late stoppage.

I cannot see Katsidis winnning this, he is a big puncher but I cant see him getting to Khan with his short arms. Precott has pipe cleaner arms and had a good reach, Katsidis would need to get on the inside, Khan is just way too fast.

I cannot see Katsidis winnning this, he is a big puncher but I cant see him getting to Khan with his short arms. Precott has pipe cleaner arms and had a good reach, Katsidis would need to get on the inside, Khan is just way too fast.

Gomez and Limond didn't have long arms either, and they were able to floor him. IMO Katsidis (and Maidana too, BTW) is a type of fighter that you can't outrun without making any contact on inside. They are just relentlessly charging forward, eating or slipping punches, and eventually they will GET to you. And I can just imagine what would happen to Khan if one of those guys will catch him clean.

I will go with power and determination of Katsidis on this one.

I cannot see Khan losing, I still think he's going to get better under Freddie.

I like Katsidis. He's got a bit of craft, power and guts. He's also coming off a good win against Mitchell. But Khan is not a good option for him. Yes, he may trouble Amir's questionable beard, but he's going to take a hell of a lot of punishment for every clean hit. Khan is bigger, faster, more accurate, has tremendous fitness and the best cornerman in the business.

I won't rule out a Katsidis win completely. But the smart money is on him taking a beating.