Who wins this Cruiserweight showdown in their primes?

Who wins this Cruiserweight showdown in their primes?


James Toney isn't in his prime at cruiserweight. Holyfield was a monster at cruiser and would have worn down James and stopped him in the late rounds.

holy would have beaten james within an inch of his life at cruiser, its not really a fair comparison toney is far smaller in his prime.

its like comparing rj in his prime to heavies, it just aint fair

Holyfield would win by midround tko.

everyone knows i am a big Toney fan, but Holy beats him in his prime, Toney is tough as nails, so i don't think he gets KO'd.

Evander for me too

Wow, I am pleasantly surprised to learn that there are still some people on this board with a good head on their shoulders. :D

i see holyfield just having to much of an intensity level for toney at that stage of his career, i'm not sure if he would knock toney out, but he would win by a UD.

holyfield, ofcourse, he's old now, so....

Holyfield would win it easily! Holyfield was FANTASTIC!

James Toney