Who wins and how?

Am I the only one who thinks this could be a intresting fight

lol sorry man
i never saw n'dou vs witter so i can't really tell
i never saw n'dou vs cotto either lol
all i know is cotto and witter both beat N'dou, so it should be a decent bout

i think cotto is better. has faced better opposition. n'dou is good not great.
mayewather beat sosa in 12 RDS, cotto destroyed him in 4.
soon enuff he'll beat corely too.
witter needs better opposition IMO

just did sum research on witter. it was those KD's that won him the fight against N'DOu, otherwise wud've been Majority Draw. Cotto's deciision was 115-113, 116-112, and 117-111. i agree on the 116-112.
witter one loss against judah, granted it was a decision. but overall cotto is much better IMO

Cotto would win.

Who wins and how?

It would be interesting, i'd pick Cotto because he's the better boxer. Witter can punch and is awkward so i'd give him a chance.

Witter has talented but he gotta stop ****ing around and work on his jab.

Cotto will win this fight without a doubt.

Cotto within 5

cotto would destroy witter...if witter tries to be like naseem again in a fight with cotto...cotto would definitely hurt him...ndou has wide loopying punches so its not as hard.......cottso left hook would hurt witter...........cotto within 5

Witter is an interesting fighter but he gets lazy, if you gat lazy aginst Cotto you get run over. I think Cotto would eventully ware him down too hard.

There you guys go again. Talking all about Cottos offense but not about Witter who is a lefty and probally hits harder. How will Cotto deal with that

There you guys go again. Talking all about Cottos offense but not about Witter who is a lefty and probally hits harder. How will Cotto deal with that

You dont think cotto has a good enuf defense for witter?He can be a VERy patient fighter, IMO./Also i dont know how this traditionaly has happened with fighters, but is a lefty still as dangerous against a left handed fighter (like cotto), as much as he would be against an orthodox fighter??

I think junior has more power than cotto, he had N'Dou hurt on quite a few occasions in this fight, if he hadn't injured his hand i could have seen him knocking N'Dou out.
N'Dou took most of cotto's big shots well.

cotto is a better all round boxer with a better defence than witter, but cotto's chin would be tested, against a big puncher in witter.

wiiter with a point win and he knocks cotto down once in the mid rounds
would be a good fight thou
and who ever said cooto has mush better oposition is worng

cotto has not fight anyone of note until corely then i will say he just edges it on better opposition and dont metion pinto cos he was and over hyped and not up to much

witter holds his head to high and exposed for my liking, interesting fight though gatti witter is more likely to happen.

wiiter with a point win and he knocks cotto down once in the mid rounds
would be a good fight thou
and who ever said cooto has mush better oposition is worng

cotto has not fight anyone of note until corely then i will say he just edges it on better opposition and dont metion pinto cos he was and over hyped and not up to much
Sounds like DLT either has another username or we just found his #1 fan.

Sounds like DLT either has another username or we just found his #1 fan.
Im not dissrespecting him but thats the truth. You guys act like I hate Cotto and says that he sucks. I have never said anything like that.

I said that I really like him and think that he could be great but he hasnt done anything to say that he will be and he hasnt done no where near anything for all of you to be picking him over all the top fighters. Thats all I have been saying

Witter by UD. Cotto's good, but he is one dimensional. He only fights going forward. He leaves himself open to lead rights and his defense is subpar. A good boxer with quickness and power will beat him.

I don't recall ever saying that I'd pick him over all the top fighters right now. Now having said that I do think that in time he will be good enough to beat all the top fighters in the division, the key words there is "in time". Right now I would however say he has a good shot at beating everyone at 140 except for Tszyu and PBF, that's right now. At this time next year and hellmaybe even by the end of 2005 IMO he would have a damn good shot at the twoo of them as well!

he is one dimensional. He only fights going forward. He leaves himself open to lead rights and his defense is subpar

I could not disagree more with you. . . all this may apply to witter but not to cotto. Watch some of his fights please.

I could not disagree more with you. . . all this may apply to witter but not to cotto. Watch some of his fights please.

I have three of his fights on video. Sounds like you're in denial.

I tell you what's most interesting about this thread, whether you rate Witter or not - before last Saturday, no one would have even considered creating a thread like this, or of having it taken seriously. That says a lot about Witter's profile since the N'Dou fight.

cotto wins this one

I have three of his fights on video. Sounds like you're in denial.


Sounds like you have no clue what you're talking about.

Sounds like you have no clue what you're talking about.

Looks like you're a Cotto nuthugger. Dude, he hasn't fought anyone worth mentioning!!

Looks like you're a Cotto nuthugger. Dude, he hasn't fought anyone worth mentioning!!


Yes, you're right I'm a Cotto nuthugger and he's the most overrated fighter in the world. He has average defense and skills and he can only fight going forwards.

There you have it folks...straight from the Alpha Male...a.k.a. the chief authority on Miguel Cotto. :rolleyes:

I'd love to see it; the very orthodox, often described as flawless young comer versus the very unorthodox veteran southpaw puncher. It'd be a case of doin all the wrong things ... and benefitting from it for Witter.

Or so he hopes.