catchweight 138. Who will you pick??

Judah for me

Valero wins. Judah is at his best in the 140 division, nothing higher or less.

Just watch Valero fight, it's hard to not think he will win.

Valero wins. Judah is at his best in the 140 division, nothing higher or less.

Just watch Valero fight, it's hard to not think he will win.

I disagree. Valero is not proven at an elite level and still drops his hands and has his chin in the air.

For all Judah's faults he was a supremely gifted fighter who at jr welter only lost to an all time great Kostya Tszyu. Valero has never been in the ring with anyone as good as Zab at any weight, let alone the highest weight he's ever fought at.

I see this fight going much like Zabs fight with Micky Ward. Valero may win a few rounds, but the difference in skill level and talent are obvious.

[/B]

I disagree. Valero is not proven at an elite level and still drops his hands and has his chin in the air.

For all Judah's faults he was a supremely gifted fighter who at jr welter only lost to an all time great Kostya Tszyu. Valero has never been in the ring with anyone as good as Zab at any weight, let alone the highest weight he's ever fought at.

I see this fight going much like Zabs fight with Micky Ward. Valero may win a few rounds, but the difference in skill level and talent are obvious.
Valero may win a few rounds, but the difference in skill level and talent are obvious.

Well, if you look at his record it's clear the dude got some pop in his punches. Remind that Zab is a quitter despite of his physical talents.

Valero wins. Judah is showboat. Valero is the harder working fighter.