I ll go with Edgar!
Who you got?

Dirty Nightmare beats the dog**** out of him.

E

Frankie Edgar makes Diego look like a tool.

Agreed...Frankie impressed me against Sherk. His boxing looked great.

Frankie takes it by UD.

Diego would walk right through him. I love Frankie but he only beat Sherk cuz Sean wanted to box most of the fight. Diego's stand up is sick as you see how he ripped Clay. He's also stronger then Frankie and has better submissions.

Diego vs Gray Maynerd should happen for the number one contention on the line

He ripped Clay cause Clay doesn't know how to throw a punch. Frankie picks him apart.

He ripped Clay cause Clay doesn't know how to throw a punch. Frankie picks him apart.

he might not be super accurate but clay can strike to it was more of Diego being pinpoint and fast.

Franks got good boxing but the same can be said as Sherk isnt a super good striker.

Diego's got more strength and power and if Jon Fitch couldnt ko him or Florian couldnt submit him I doubt Edgar can.

Frank can maybe outstrike him but Diegos standup looks real good right now

I didn't say Frankie will KO him, but I think his striking is superior and will win a UD. Im kind of biased though, cause I really don't like Diego too much. He comes off as prick most of the time. But he did look great against Guida, I can't deny that.

SEE poll results. Also, sell all your belongings and place their monetary value all in on Edgar if he ever fights Sanchez. You will be indigent after you place said wager.

E

although frankie has moved quickly up the ranks after his upset win over sean sherk.

diego is way too much for him and primed. and the match will not happen, until at least after diego gets a title shot, which will only make him better, and therefor

result - edgar has no chance if the fights ever made

Frankie wins with better fluid striking and a better wrestling.

Frankie by UD.

Diego's striking it still tight and robotic. Frankie's striking with his fight against Sherk was very nice.

However Diego pushes a hard pace. But I still think Frankie wins