Who wins in a battle of hand to hand combat?

Who wins if they both had equal starships at their command?

Kirk

http://www.geocities.com/phineasbg/krksmilb.jpg

Picard

http://members.aol.com/lucyhardng/poembook/picard3.gif

I think Kirk would win in hand to hand combat and picard would win in a strategic battle.

I never really got down on Star Trek...I always liked Star Wars more. Kirk wins just because he's Shatner.

the whole star trek/wars thing has gotten out of control :p
sorry but maybe im missing something, believe me ive tried to like these types of shows/movies .i just cant get intrested.no offense to the "trekkies" or whoever else its just my opinion.

btw i voted for kirk cause of the fibre adds

the whole star trek/wars thing has gotten out of control :p
sorry but maybe im missing something, believe me ive tried to like these types of shows/movies .i just cant get intrested.no offense to the "trekkies" or whoever else its just my opinion.

btw i voted for kirk cause of the fibre adds

I do like the Star trek series and Star Wars movies, but I'm not a trekkie. I'm not one of those guys who dresses up and goes to conventions and collects memorabelia.

I liked the original Star Trek and Next Generation but none of the others.
I have never watched a Stars Wars flik in it's entirety. Seems to me that Lucas is an overgrown child ...and not even a cool one! The characters and situations are just plain silly.

And Kirk bests Picard in anything except chess.

Capt. Kirk is the Man...

But Capt. Picard looks meaner...

I do like the Star trek series and Star Wars movies, but I'm not a trekkie. I'm not one of those guys who dresses up and goes to conventions and collects memorabelia.
well thats good to know. have you seen the movie Trekkies?

well thats good to know. have you seen the movie Trekkies?

I think I did. The Star Trek dentist office looked kind of cool. But most of it was rediculous.

I think I did. The Star Trek dentist office looked kind of cool. But most of it was rediculous.

i thought that movie was hilarious. all those trekkies were serious. i love laughing at people like that, i wonder if they know they are nerds?

Picard is indeed the master of strategy. Stuff you Kirk!