View Full Version : Sherdog.com’s Pound-for-Pound Top 10


Palma
05-29-2009, 11:58 PM
Sherdog.com’s Pound-for-Pound Top 10

Friday, May 29, 2009

Sherdog.com’s Pound-for-Pound Top 10 The pound-for-pound world in mixed martial arts is typically seen through the prism of the “big three” -- Anderson Silva, Georges St. Pierre and Fedor Emelianenko -- and then everybody else. However, Lyoto Machida capturing the light heavyweight mantle raises the question: “Is there room for a fourth?”

Machida’s destructive blowout of Rashad Evans to claim 205-pound supremacy was the most brilliant of his career and has left many fans and critics wondering who can beat “The Dragon.” Regardless of whom the most ideal candidate might be, as the leader of the pack in one of MMA’s most talented and star-rich divisions, championship consistency would put the Belem, Brazil, native into rarified air with the sport’s other pound-for-pound kings.

It is an active time for MMA’s elite fighters, as well. Seven of these 10 pound-for-pound entrants have potential bouts on the slate in the next 10 weeks, making for a fantastic early summer for the sport.

1. Anderson Silva (24-4)
Silva’s April title defense against Thales Leites was exactly the sort of performance that can undermine any man’s claim to being a pound-for-pound king. Sensing “The Spider” needed a stiffer challenge, Zuffa lined up a bout against former light heavyweight champion Forrest Griffin at UFC 101 on Aug. 8. Silva began his career by besting then top welterweights like Hayato “Mach” Sakurai and Tetsuji Kato and then moved on to dominate the middleweight division. A win over Griffin would make Silva MMA’s first man with top five-caliber victories across three weight classes.

2. Georges St. Pierre (18-2)
Over the last four years, no fighter has more victories against accomplished, outstanding opponents than St. Pierre. However, despite avenging his April 2007 loss to Matt Serra 12 months later, the specter of his smashing at the hands of “The Terror” still looms. With another great challenger in Thiago Alves on deck for his third title defense at UFC 100 on July 11, St. Pierre can continue to pave over the Serra debacle with exceptional victories.

3. Fedor Emelianenko (30-1, 1 NC)
No one has ever reigned in MMA like Emelianenko. The only knocks on the sport’s heavyweight king has been the fact that he’s plagued by a thinner division than some of the sport’s other stalwarts and has not fought his best contemporaries recently. Fortunately, this has changed over the last year with his demolitions of Tim Sylvia and Andrei Arlovski. If an August bout with Josh Barnett comes to fruition, it will mark Emelianenko’s third consecutive match against a top 10 former UFC heavyweight champion; it’s the kind of schedule that befits the sport’s epic heavyweight.


4. Lyoto Machida (15-0)
Machida’s sub-nine-minute blowout of Rashad Evans was a bold statement proclaiming his arrival as MMA’s light heavyweight king. “The Dragon” has considerable pound-for-pound upside, as well, as the UFC’s 205-pound division offers him a slew of accomplished and outstanding fighters on which to build a resume. Unfortunately, his first title defense will not be the anticipated showdown with Quinton “Rampage” Jackson, who is now bound for coaching duty on Season 10 of “The Ultimate Fighter.”

5. Miguel Torres (37-1)
Seventeen straight wins over a nearly six-year-long undefeated run is telling when it comes to Torres’ divisional dominance. However, the bantamweight division remains a nascent one in mixed martial arts, and it’s only now that Torres is finally getting the opportunities to fight fellow stalwarts. Coming off a unanimous decision win against Takeya Mizugaki in of one of the year’s best bouts in April, Torres will have the chance to put yet another outstanding notch on his belt when he takes on the undefeated Brian Bowles at WEC 42 on Aug. 9.

6. B.J. Penn (13-5-1)
Skill has never been the question with Penn, who was nicknamed “The Prodigy” for a reason. However, results are the measuring stick of sporting success, especially in prizefighting, and Penn has yet to settle into the role of lightweight ruler that has always been expected of him. He will be afforded the chance to prove himself as the sport’s most dominant 155-pound athlete and put another name on his resume when he risks his UFC title against well-deserving challenger Kenny Florian at UFC 101 on Aug. 8.

7. Quinton Jackson (30-7)
In his last five fights, Jackson is 4-1 against five straight top 10 opponents in one of MMA’s deepest divisions. Needless to say, a matchup in which he attempted to reclaim the UFC title and light heavyweight mantle from Lyoto Machida would have been exactly the sort of high-stakes relevance for which the sport thirsts. Fortunately, his second “The Ultimate Fighter” coaching stint will lead to a showdown with Rashad Evans, which is nothing at which to sneeze.

8. Mike Thomas Brown (21-4)
From 1999 to 2006, Alexandre Franca Nogueira reigned over MMA’s featherweight class in its sparse and embryonic stages. However, since the division has developed fully, no fighter has stepped out and dominated. In his June 7 rematch with Urijah Faber, the unassuming Brown will have the chance to become the first 145-pounder to truly reign over his best contemporaries in the weight class; should he win, it will mark his fourth straight top 10 win. Better still, with the likes of Wagnney Fabiano and Jose Aldo in the WEC’s ranks, Brown has no shortage of strong challengers waiting in the wings.

9. Thiago Alves (16-3)
MMA is a sport in which fans and pundits tend to pore over, celebrate and critique the resumes of champions. However, MMA is also replete with rock-solid contenders who have accrued multiple standout wins. Alves had arguably the best year of any fighter in 2008, as he knocked off three consecutive top 10 opponents in a great division and earned himself a title shot against Georges St. Pierre at UFC 100 in July.

10. Rashad Evans (13-1-1)
Evans rose to the top of the light heavyweight division in 2008. However, 2009 opened brutally for Evans, who was outmatched and blown away by new divisional king Lyoto Machida. Unlike many other deposed champions, Evans has the chance to rectify his resume in short order due to the strength of his divisional contemporaries. Evans’ road to redemption will now run through Season 10 of “The Ultimate Fighter,” as he’ll coach against fellow 205-pound stalwart Quinton “Rampage” Jackson, setting up a clash later this year.

DeltaSigChi4
05-30-2009, 12:15 AM
****dog*

E

Don Corleone
05-30-2009, 12:28 AM
****dog*

E

Alright smart-ass. Give us an explanation of your top 5 P4P picks and tell us why Sherdog "has it wrong". Tell us your reasoning as to each fighter's ranking and why you rank them the way they are.

F l i c k e r
05-30-2009, 12:33 AM
****dog*

E

Agreed. Because of this....


5. Miguel Torres (37-1)
Seventeen straight wins over a nearly six-year-long undefeated run is telling when it comes to Torres’ divisional dominance. However, the bantamweight division remains a nascent one in mixed martial arts, and it’s only now that Torres is finally getting the opportunities to fight fellow stalwarts. Coming off a unanimous decision win against Takeya Mizugaki in of one of the year’s best bouts in April, Torres will have the chance to put yet another outstanding notch on his belt when he takes on the undefeated Brian Bowles at WEC 42 on Aug. 9.


**** him. First of all the division is talentless. Second of all, he is the biggest man in the division. I dont give a damn what perspectives people have, his natural weight isn't 135 period! Its like watching Paul Williams try to campaign at 140 in boxing. Of course he will win! The same size as GSP, no way in hell is this man natural 135. ****ing Urijah Faber isn't even a natural 145. How the hell would Miguel Torres be a natural bantam?

p4p is smaller dudes with the skill to beat bigger dudes. All Miguel Torres does is bully smaller dudes in a talentless division. Epic Fail.

Klitschko2011
05-30-2009, 12:58 AM
Terrible Rankings. Silva is boring and overrated, he has 4 losses and looked like **** in his last 2 fights.

My Top 5 P4P Rankings

1. Fedor Emelianenko
2. Georges St.Pierre
3. Lyoto Machida
4. Anderson Silva
5. B.J. Penn

DeltaSigChi4
05-30-2009, 02:07 AM
My pound-for-pound ranking is unchanged from the beginning of this year, lone exception being Aoki Shinya dropping off after his loss to the bigger Mach.

E

Nicky Fatton
05-30-2009, 02:20 AM
I can't stand Sherdog rankings because they are heavily in bed with Zuffa despite all the bull**** drama you hear about press credentials and other nonsense. Sherwood knows where his bread is buttered the most and if you have seen a picture of the man you would know how much he loves his bread n butter.

Here are my Top 5 P4P rankings despite the fact that P4P is meaningless and only exists to provide obsessive fans of the sport a ceaseless and neverending topic to banter and rave about.

1. Fedor Emelianenko

- This is self-explanatory to anyone who is a fan of MMA. Last 2 wins over Top 5 opponents with a 3rd against Barnett coming shortly. Has ruled the HW division for 6 years and is light years ahead of everyone in the game. Fedor will be #1 for as long as he competes actively in the sport of MMA.

2. Georges St. Pierre

- continues to evolve into a superstar at WW and takes on the best possible opponents at his weight class.

3. Anderson Silva

- Would be #2 on this list but his last 2 performances have been subpar and disheartening considering the fact he couldn't put away two opponents who didn't deserve to be in the cage with him from the start.

4. Lyoto Machida

- Is here on this list because of his impressive ascension to the top of LHW. If Lyoto can continue his undefeated streak with wins over Shogun, Rampage and other top LHW's he will quickly move into the #2 spot.

5. B.J. Penn

- is here because of his record at LW. A loss to Florian takes him off the list.

DeltaSigChi4
05-30-2009, 03:19 AM
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v604/DeltaSigChi4/Larry-Jeff.jpg
Back when he was "slim".

E

Tha_Greatest
05-30-2009, 03:44 AM
what is this, a smokers website

BlueberryMuffin
05-30-2009, 04:20 AM
Pound for Pound Top 5:

1. Fedor (HW)
2. Anderson (MW)
3. GSP (WW)
4. BJ (LW)
5. Lyoto (LHW)

JoHnNyBoXeR
05-30-2009, 10:09 AM
1. Machida
2. Fedor
3. Pierrre
4. Silva

Don Corleone
05-30-2009, 01:23 PM
1. Silva
2. St. Pierre
3. Fedor
4. Machida

FloydsEra
05-30-2009, 03:03 PM
Fedor not #1


You fail, *****es

TRAVI$
05-30-2009, 03:15 PM
Silva
Fedor
GSP
Machida

Mayorga-Rules
05-30-2009, 03:17 PM
Agreed. Because of this....


5. Miguel Torres (37-1)
Seventeen straight wins over a nearly six-year-long undefeated run is telling when it comes to Torres’ divisional dominance. However, the bantamweight division remains a nascent one in mixed martial arts, and it’s only now that Torres is finally getting the opportunities to fight fellow stalwarts. Coming off a unanimous decision win against Takeya Mizugaki in of one of the year’s best bouts in April, Torres will have the chance to put yet another outstanding notch on his belt when he takes on the undefeated Brian Bowles at WEC 42 on Aug. 9.


**** him. First of all the division is talentless. Second of all, he is the biggest man in the division. I dont give a damn what perspectives people have, his natural weight isn't 135 period! Its like watching Paul Williams try to campaign at 140 in boxing. Of course he will win! The same size as GSP, no way in hell is this man natural 135. ****ing Urijah Faber isn't even a natural 145. How the hell would Miguel Torres be a natural bantam?

p4p is smaller dudes with the skill to beat bigger dudes. All Miguel Torres does is bully smaller dudes in a talentless division. Epic Fail.


Damn, i never followed the division but i saw his fight against Tapia And he looked good. I always suspected the level of the 135 pounds division but now there is someone who tells it.
For the 145 pounds, i think there is talent but the thing in MMA is that i think the guys who aren't talented enough to fight at 155 will rather fight in featherweight.

My P4P ranking would be:
1/ Fedor
2/ GSP
3/ Anderson Silva
4/ Lyoto Machida
5/ Bj Penn
6/ Faber
7/ Miguel Torres
8/ Mousasi
9/ Alves
10/Rampage

mindreader
05-30-2009, 03:56 PM
bj penn is overrated