At first i liked Mef more, but I realized that Red is much more lyrical and creative then Mef and sharp as **** at times, where im like damn now thats rappin your ass off. Red's albums malpractice and Red gon wild are dope albums imo, and he has pretty dope beats. Mef's last 2 album where garbage give or take a few tracks. Red is surpassing Mef these days. He is also ne of my fav MC's overall.

I think its a tie...Overall i think method man is a little bit better as a rapper but redmans discography >> Meths...

Tical = 5/0
Tical 2000 = 4.5/5
Tical Prequel = 0/5
4:21 = 4/5

Whut Thee Album = 5/5
Dare Iz a Darkside = 4/5
Muddy Waters = 5/5
Doc's da Name 2000 = 4/5
Malpractice = 4/5
Red Gone Wild = 2.5/5

red all day...whut thee album, dare iz a darkside, muddy watterz...nuff said

altho i love meth

I like Method Man alot more than Redman. Meth is top 3 for me as far as favorites.

As far as solo discography comparisons, Redman is better. However if you include all meth's stuff with wu-tang and features....its closer.

But as far as just solo discography, I give the nod to Red.

However, as far as who is the better rapper? Its very very close....but I think Meth has a better flow and better voice than Redman.

I agree with you Truth, its a tough call. I also would rather listen to meth then red, but when i look at it from all angles, its very close. And that was a good point bringin up all the songs Meth did with Wu, Redman has also had his share of classic collabs...its a really a coin toss in my opinion.

tough call, I'd say Redman. Better catalog.

I agree with you Truth, its a tough call. I also would rather listen to meth then red, but when i look at it from all angles, its very close. And that was a good point bringin up all the songs Meth did with Wu, Redman has also had his share of classic collabs...its a really a coin toss in my opinion.

Yeah thats true, I should have mentioned Red's collabs....

and i agree that it could go either way.

I have to say though, Redman has been outdoing Meth latley on the Blackout 2 songs.

Not to say Meth isn't doing his thing, but I just think Redman has been even sharper based on the three songs I've heard.

Meth for me, but only just.

meth that dude smell me? the hood respect meth more than red........smell me?

as a rapper, i have to go meth too...cuz he more gutter with his flow and voice...smell me?

Redman 116-112

Not a tough choice for me, Red is better.

Meth is not even close to Red, man people sleep on red since day including myself, meth just cant keep up with redz skillz at all!!! You guys r nutz!!!

Pay attention and listen to the lyrics red is so underated it blows my mine.

method man is that dude...

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/hKrFqarEfPk&hl=en&fs=1"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/hKrFqarEfPk&hl=en&fs=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>