View Full Version : New starting 11 rules


kenny91
02-21-2008, 06:12 PM
Anyone heard yet?

Apparently some dude on the FA board wants to enforce a new role; all english teams have to field at least 5 english players.

chelseas ****ed lol

anyways what are ur views? (who will benefit, who will suffer and do u think its good or bad?)

:feedback:

oovavu
02-21-2008, 06:13 PM
Good for the national team, but the standard of play will drop a little.

DURAN_IS_GOD
02-21-2008, 06:19 PM
as a villa fan it wont affect us in the slightest as we have a large english/british base of players

arsenal essentially would be screwed as would chelsea at the present minute. I guess its a good idea in principle but cant see it being enforced

kenny91
02-21-2008, 06:22 PM
haha sweet im a Villan too .. we would not be fussed the slightest and it would bring us even closer to our european dreams cos the top 4 will be droppin their foreign players (who happen to be their best) like flies

we'll be laughin.

Don Gorgon
02-21-2008, 06:25 PM
I can't see how they can enforce this. Arsenal would be ruined if this came into play.

It wouldn't adversely affect my team (Spurs) to be honest.

Flab
02-21-2008, 06:50 PM
I think you should also be limited to buying 3 players every transfer season.
This is a great idea that will **** over Chelski and Frenchnal.

kenny91
02-21-2008, 07:37 PM
I think you should also be limited to buying 3 players every transfer season.
This is a great idea that will **** over Chelski and Frenchnal.


good idea RiZOOM ! i think the 5 english players rule and ur suggestion for only 3 transfers per window would be great and will help english football to redeme its title ENGLISH!

P4PKING_2008
02-21-2008, 07:44 PM
If you think about it our National team will eiether become great or extremely poor and our premiership will become a joke due to lack of ability. Also, what about Europe? I doubt we would want to play the best in Europe with 5 youth products.

Utd should do well as should spurs and villa, but the real losers are Arsenal who have been buying foreign youth for years. :owned:

Flab
02-21-2008, 08:17 PM
good idea RiZOOM ! i think the 5 english players rule and ur suggestion for only 3 transfers per window would be great and will help english football to redeme its title ENGLISH!

You get teams like Chelsea who buy a whole new team every window. The lesser clubs miss out on players because the bigger clubs buy them all and bench them all. 3 transfers per window would put a stop to this.

Flab
02-21-2008, 08:20 PM
Or, to make it more acceptable only 3 foreign players signed every season, but no limit on English players...hmm.

kenny91
02-21-2008, 08:33 PM
yeah sounds good

PeROxiDE
02-22-2008, 01:11 PM
Anyone heard yet?

Apparently some dude on the FA board wants to enforce a new role; all english teams have to field at least 5 english players.

chelseas ****ed lol

anyways what are ur views? (who will benefit, who will suffer and do u think its good or bad?)

:feedback:

What about my team, Cardiff City? They are a Welsh team, but because they play in the English league, does that mean they have to field 5 english players?

Or, to make it more acceptable only 3 foreign players signed every season, but no limit on English players...hmm.

Better than all the ideas the FA have ever come up with....

kenny91
02-22-2008, 08:50 PM
Or, to make it more acceptable only 3 foreign players signed every season, but no limit on English players...hmm.

i reckon with the 5 english players on the startin 11 rule and ur idea for just 3 foreigners max per window but no limit on English players. Id think we'd also have to enforce a rule on how many english players are allowed out of the country, because obviously some key english players are gonna think 'ah this i ****' and would wanna leave. To put a stop to that i think a rule likel; only 3 english players per english league are allowed to leave the country PER SEASON.

:feedback:

thanks for the comments so far guys :banana: