1)Sugar Ray Robinson
2)Clay/Ali
3)JC Chavez
4)Joe Louis
5)Willie Pep
6)Marvin Hagler
7)Roberto Duran
8)Barney Ross
9)Henry Armstrong
10)tie John L Sullivan/Jack Johnson

Not a bad list, though i disagree in some areas: Chavez is way, way too high, Armstrong is too low for my taste, and i wouldn't have Sullivan or Johnson in my top 10. However, those are my opinions, and that's why we have different lists. All the fighters you mentioned are great.

And i was glad to see that the Klitchkos or Pacquiao weren't on your list.

Hey, nice to see Chavez on a P4P list. I wouldnt have him that high but Im glad to see him there, most people dont even think about considering him. Hes one of my top 3 favorite fighters. Great fighter.

i havent seen a lot of the old fighters so i can only judge the ones i have seen and some of them would include(in no particular order) old school- sugar ray robinson,roberto duran,marvin hagler, muhammed ali and ezzard charles. recent roy jones and bernard hopkins. im sure some slipped my mind but these guys are my favs :)