View Full Version : Who is the most Underappreciated Fighter?


Mr. Ryan
10-21-2004, 04:13 PM
The boxing game is typically dominated by a handful of fighters who command the spotlight because of their photogenic personalities and their ability to give the perfect quote. But what about those who fall under the radar? The ones that are the equals of the Roy Jones' and De La Hoya's yet don't get the fan fare of the aforementioned pugs. Here are a few candidates:

Antonio Margarito
Winky Wright
Juan Manuel Marquez
Jose Luis Castillo
Glen Johnson

Who is your pick?

Fat Shamz
10-21-2004, 04:16 PM
i just read ur profile, says that u like old scool rap, wat kind? tell me, as i too listen to old scool rap like 24/7

Sir_Jose
10-21-2004, 04:19 PM
The boxing game is typically dominated by a handful of fighters who command the spotlight because of their photogenic personalities and their ability to give the perfect quote. But what about those who fall under the radar? The ones that are the equals of the Roy Jones' and De La Hoya's yet don't get the fan fare of the aforementioned pugs. Here are a few candidates:

Antonio Margarito
Winky Wright
Juan Manuel Marquez
Jose Luis Castillo
Glen Johnson

Who is your pick?

Margarito has been exposed and Winky up until Mosley had lost ever single time he had stepped up.

I would say its Castillo. Two wins over a prime Stevie Johnston, Cesar Bazan, Juan Lazcano and in the eyes of most is 1-1 against Floyd Mayweather.

BrooklynBomber
10-21-2004, 04:23 PM
Castillo is way too underappriciated. Floyd clearly lost that fight.

Mr. Ryan
10-21-2004, 04:27 PM
i just read ur profile, says that u like old scool rap, wat kind? tell me, as i too listen to old scool rap like 24/7
I listen to A Tribe Called Quest, Slick Rick, Onyx, and Black Moon mostly. I listen to all old school really.

elveiel
10-21-2004, 04:37 PM
Castillo is way too underappriciated. Floyd clearly lost that fight.

The first fight was Castillo's but the second Mayweather won.

Castillo is underated.

Verbl_Kint
10-21-2004, 04:58 PM
I'd have to go with Jose Luis Castillo. JMM wasn't that impressive against Salido and Winky knows Sugar Shane's game so much that Mosley couldn't do anything

MetalVomit
10-21-2004, 04:59 PM
I listen to A Tribe Called Quest, Slick Rick, Onyx, and Black Moon mostly. I listen to all old school really.



dont forget Rakim, the Ali of hip hop.

scap
10-21-2004, 05:48 PM
JL Castillo without question, he beat mayweather fairly easy when you watch the first fight over. Castillo would have in my opinion been too damn strong for Corrales and if Casamayor fights like he did against Seda it will be a cake walk for JL!

Zhen
10-21-2004, 06:49 PM
Jose, I wouldn't really say Margarito was exposed by Santos, since junior middle and welterweight are two very different divisions.
Margarito should just stay at 147.

(1) Ronald "Winky" Wright
(2) "El 7 Mares" Antonio Margarito
(3) "Tuaman" David Tua (ok, maybe not that underappreciated)
(4) Jose Luis Castillo
And to round out the top five of underappreciated fighters,
(5) Montell Griffin (because he was recently robbed by Hoye)

And I will defend that statement that he was robbed by Hoye

marvdave
10-21-2004, 07:29 PM
Jose, I wouldn't really say Margarito was exposed by Santos, since junior middle and welterweight are two very different divisions.
Margarito should just stay at 147.

(1) Ronald "Winky" Wright
(2) "El 7 Mares" Antonio Margarito
(3) "Tuaman" David Tua (ok, maybe not that underappreciated)
(4) Jose Luis Castillo
And to round out the top five of underappreciated fighters,
(5) Montell Griffin (because he was recently robbed by Hoye)

And I will defend that statement that he was robbed by Hoye

Winky was never underappreciated, just ducked by the champs. I think all fans respect his ability at this point. Tua isn't either, if anything, Tua is overratted.


honestly, I can't think of anyone that is underappreciated..I'm sure some will come to me.

Sir_Jose
10-21-2004, 08:06 PM
Winky was never underappreciated, just ducked by the champs. I think all fans respect his ability at this point. Tua isn't either, if anything, Tua is overratted.


honestly, I can't think of anyone that is underappreciated..I'm sure some will come to me.

Want to explain to me how Winky was "Ducked" when he had recieved shots at the WBA and IBF belts.

Thats the biggest damn myth in boxing that Wright was ducked. He wasn't ducked he just kept losing every time he stepped up.

marvdave
10-21-2004, 08:20 PM
Want to explain to me how Winky was "Ducked" when he had recieved shots at the WBA and IBF belts.

Thats the biggest damn myth in boxing that Wright was ducked. He wasn't ducked he just kept losing every time he stepped up.

sure, if thats what you want. If your referring to the Vasquez fight, that was 10 years ago or so and he was soundly beaten. As far as Vargas, it is my opinion that he won that fight. If your opinion is that the champs didn't duck him over the last couple of years, I would respectfully disagree becuase I feel his Boxing ability and the fact that his name didn't bring PPv dollars where the factors in the "ducking".

Shane Mosley stepped up and took the challenge when he didn't have to and look what happened to him.

Sir_Jose
10-21-2004, 08:28 PM
sure, if thats what you want. If your referring to the Vasquez fight, that was 10 years ago or so and he was soundly beaten. As far as Vargas, it is my opinion that he won that fight. If your opinion is that the champs didn't duck him over the last couple of years, I would respectfully disagree becuase I feel his Boxing ability and the fact that his name didn't bring PPv dollars where the factors in the "ducking".

Shane Mosley stepped up and took the challenge when he didn't have to and look what happened to him.

I felt he lost the Vargas fight Wright faded very badly in that fight and just pretty much stopped fighting in the late round and let Vargas come one and take the fight.

Dont forget Wright also lost to Hary Simon during thise time when he was being "Ducked".

marvdave
10-21-2004, 08:35 PM
I felt he lost the Vargas fight Wright faded very badly in that fight and just pretty much stopped fighting in the late round and let Vargas come one and take the fight.

Dont forget Wright also lost to Hary Simon during thise time when he was being "Ducked".

I don't remember the Simon fight..what year was that? Was that recently? for the life of me, I don't recall that one.

regardless, he was high risk/low reward over the last five years or so. I bet we don't hear DLH, Trinidad or Hopkins calling him out anytime soon. I'm not saying they are afraid of him, but definitely they won't waste their time with that style.

Sir_Jose
10-21-2004, 08:41 PM
I don't remember the Simon fight..what year was that? Was that recently? for the life of me, I don't recall that one.

regardless, he was high risk/low reward over the last five years or so. I bet we don't hear DLH, Trinidad or Hopkins calling him out anytime soon. I'm not saying they are afraid of him, but definitely they won't waste their time with that style.

The Simon fight was right before the Vargas fight in 98.

jabsRstiff
10-22-2004, 08:15 AM
"I felt he lost the Vargas fight Wright faded very badly in that fight and just pretty much stopped fighting in the late round and let Vargas come one and take the fight."

yeah, but "Oscar EASILY beat Trinidad" according to you.


You're generaly a good poster, but your Mexican bias has been on display recently.

Mr. Ryan
05-23-2006, 04:37 AM
dont forget Rakim, the Ali of hip hop.
Rakim is cool. My **** is Eric B is President, that song is ****ing classic.

Violent Demise
05-23-2006, 05:12 AM
Ike Quartey and Joel Casamayor. Rafael Marquez also.

benjamindallas5
05-23-2006, 05:26 AM
The boxing game is typically dominated by a handful of fighters who command the spotlight because of their photogenic personalities and their ability to give the perfect quote. But what about those who fall under the radar? The ones that are the equals of the Roy Jones' and De La Hoya's yet don't get the fan fare of the aforementioned pugs. Here are a few candidates:

Antonio Margarito
Winky Wright
Juan Manuel Marquez
Jose Luis Castillo
Glen Johnson

Who is your pick?


Out of those names I would say Glen Johnson

Weird User
05-23-2006, 05:30 AM
Ike Ibeabuchi was underappreciated. I personaly think he was the 8th greatest heavyweight of all time. There are a lot of non believers out there, that don't consider him great!

benjamindallas5
05-23-2006, 05:33 AM
Ike Ibeabuchi was underappreciated. I personaly think he was the 8th greatest heavyweight of all time. There are a lot of non believers out there, that don't consider him great!

You sir are a retarded Homo! Stop posting!

moraleskospacisback
05-23-2006, 07:04 AM
Ike Quartey and Joel Casamayor. Rafael Marquez also.

^^^^^Thats some true ass ****, casamayor could be undefeated and is in the mind of some, same wit Quartey, and what else can u say about rafael marquez, a ko machine, i hope he moves up or down to get some big fights, montiel or gonzalez, vasquez, harrison, somebody...

RichPorter
05-23-2006, 07:28 AM
juan diaz, joe calzaghe, jose luis castillo