View Full Version : How did you score Bisping vs. Hamill?


neils7147933
09-11-2007, 08:31 PM
I reposted the "Tell Bisping how you feel" url on a myspace bulletin and got a response from someone who thought Bisping won. He said Hamill didn't do anything after Round 1.

I wonder with all of us ranting about the decision, if there are others who weren't appalled at the scores who just don't want to post.

Here's your chance - how did you score the fight?

Liaison
09-11-2007, 08:34 PM
First 2 rounds to Hamill and the last to Bisping, but with this obscure scoring system in the Promotion (which is always going to lead to tight and disputed decisions), I can see arguments being made for the second to go to Bisping.

kaps
09-12-2007, 01:40 AM
29-28 Hamill is as far as I can go, but while watching I had it 30-27....

Blair_Wells#32
09-12-2007, 02:54 AM
i had all 3 rounds for hamill with the takedowns an stand up.

Mech.
09-12-2007, 05:53 AM
Bisping has looked like crap the two times I seen him.

I thought the decision should have gone to Hamill but I expected it to go to Bisping. Hamill had a great 1st round but he could have done a lot more in the other 2 rounds.Hamill allowed the second round to be too close.

You know what I think got people all upset? It feels like a bigger robbery than it actually was if we're a little objective. Think about the scoring, Hamill won the first round, Bisping one the last round (with the second rd being close-ish) What was the difference? How decisive Hamill won the first compared round compared to how Bisping won the 3rd.But you still scored them the same,respectively, right? Take that into consideration and its really not such a big deal Bisping got the decision, even though I cant wait till he loses.

The thing I do disagree with though, is if you gave Hamill all 3 rounds, I dont see that at all.

Blair_Wells#32
09-12-2007, 12:28 PM
judged on effective striking grappling aggression and octagon control.
hamill landed shots in every round while blocking pretty much all of bispings jabs.
hamill also took down bisping at will 2 take care of the grappling in each round.
aggression was all hamill, bisping was runnin all 3 rounds, this also ties into octagon control.

thats how i have it scored for hamill 30-27.
peace.

neils7147933
09-12-2007, 01:06 PM
judged on effective striking grappling aggression and octagon control.
hamill landed shots in every round while blocking pretty much all of bispings jabs.
hamill also took down bisping at will 2 take care of the grappling in each round.
aggression was all hamill, bisping was runnin all 3 rounds, this also ties into octagon control.

thats how i have it scored for hamill 30-27.
peace.
Then why did you vote "Bisping 30-27"? l

2swell k-wells
09-12-2007, 01:35 PM
judged on effective striking grappling aggression and octagon control.
hamill landed shots in every round while blocking pretty much all of bispings jabs.
hamill also took down bisping at will 2 take care of the grappling in each round.
aggression was all hamill, bisping was runnin all 3 rounds, this also ties into octagon control.

thats how i have it scored for hamill 30-27.
peace.

Hamill's quotes sound almost simlar to yours.

Here is what he had to say about the judging:

"I think MMA is a great sport and I donít believe in any kind of a fix. The two judges that scored the win for Bisping obviously need to re-evaluate the way they score a fight. You canít win a fight when you run for three rounds. They need to study the criteria for scoring an MMA fight: effective striking, grappling, takedowns, aggression and control. Bisping did none of that in my opinion."

source mmajunkie.com

$ LegenD $
09-12-2007, 09:42 PM
bisping 3-0?...WTF?......2 cats in here actually believe that or i mean "saw" that.....damn.....hamill 2-1 in my view no doubt about it.....bad decision hope bisping man's up and signs the rematch......

2swell k-wells
09-12-2007, 11:27 PM
bisping 3-0?...WTF?......2 cats in here actually believe that or i mean "saw" that.....damn.....hamill 2-1 in my view no doubt about it.....bad decision hope bisping man's up and signs the rematch......

he already said he wanted one, didnt think he would since he didnt want to fight Hamill the 1st time. Now we see why.....that cunt.

RAESAAD
09-12-2007, 11:29 PM
I actually watched this card ,the whole thing since it was free and there wasn't any boxing on......the deaf dude won the fight and to me there was little question about it.I mean sure it was close but not close enough to declare the wrong guy the winner.

2swell k-wells
09-12-2007, 11:32 PM
although there was no boxing on you still got to see boxing judging.

Blair_Wells#32
09-13-2007, 12:35 AM
lol sorry was half asleep when i voted, so my votes for 30-27 for hamill.

American_Ninja
09-13-2007, 12:45 AM
although there was no boxing on you still got to see boxing judging.
Exactly, 2 of the judges were boxing judges. Nuff said.
Hamill 29-28

kaps
09-13-2007, 01:05 AM
I actually watched this card ,the whole thing since it was free and there wasn't any boxing on......the deaf dude won the fight and to me there was little question about it.I mean sure it was close but not close enough to declare the wrong guy the winner.


Good cover, don't want your boxing friends to know you like MMA eh?