View Full Version : Why Herb Dean stand up Gonaga/Cro Cop?
2swell k-wells 04-24-2007, 01:06 PM Ok I was watching this fight over and over cause I like to see a underdog like Gonzaga win but when Cro Cop went for the kick and Gonzaga took him down from there. Gonzaga was throwing elbow bombs on cro cop, winning the round with domination then when there is little time left the Ref (Herb Dean) stands both fighters up when Gonzaga was VERY busy on the ground. I've seen fights like Matt Hughes vs Chris Lytle where I think it was Herb Dean, Let Matt Hughes lay on top of Chris Lytle for a win. But Gonzaga was doing damage and still got stood up, u think dana/ref wanted cro cop to throw a KO kick?
You think Cro Cop is the new golden boy and Dana was helping him out for a win and title shot at Couture?? What you guys think about this? Has anyone else noticed?
me2007 04-24-2007, 01:12 PM It wouldn`t surprise me if the Dean was 'briefed' by White before the fight. He couldn`t stop that kick to the head though.
IncuFan 04-24-2007, 02:54 PM It wouldn`t surprise me if the Dean was 'briefed' by White before the fight. He couldn`t stop that kick to the head though.
LOL yeah he couldn't. Dana had big plans for Cro Cop and once that kick landed it ended. I wouldn't doubt thats what Dana told Herb Dean keep the fight on their feet as much as possible.
1bad65 04-24-2007, 03:32 PM That standup was a bad call. First off, Gonzaga was active. Second, a ref should warn you AT LEAST ONCE to get busy before standing a fight up.
Liaison 04-24-2007, 05:37 PM Simple, Herb can foresee the future, he knew what would happen next…
Easy-E 04-24-2007, 09:54 PM terrible standup, but the UFC wanted Cro Crop to win.
thats all there is too it.
2swell k-wells 04-25-2007, 10:50 AM what i was thinking, a cro cop vs couture would draw more money and fans. They should've got McCarthy to ref the damn main event, what happend to him? guess dana knew John McCarthy would call it the fight as he see's it, and knew herb dean would take dana's advice and help out cro cop if anything were to happen.
Squezze 04-25-2007, 12:07 PM what i was thinking, a cro cop vs couture would draw more money and fans. They should've got McCarthy to ref the damn main event, what happend to him? guess dana knew John McCarthy would call it the fight as he see's it, and knew herb dean would take dana's advice and help out cro cop if anything were to happen.
Seems like we're seeing Big John less and less every month. Is it possible that he's slowly phasing himself out? Maybe he's contemplating retirement, or semi-retirement. I mean, the man has to have refereed more MMA fights than any other ref.
Harms 04-25-2007, 12:57 PM Seems like we're seeing Big John less and less every month. Is it possible that he's slowly phasing himself out? Maybe he's contemplating retirement, or semi-retirement. I mean, the man has to have refereed more MMA fights than any other ref.
I don't know about him refereeing more fights than anyone. He seems to only do UFC now while Dean and Mazagatti seem to be everywhere doing smaller shows and even the Pride US events.
2swell k-wells 04-25-2007, 04:53 PM I don't know about him refereeing more fights than anyone. He seems to only do UFC now while Dean and Mazagatti seem to be everywhere doing smaller shows and even the Pride US events.
Big Jon still has more experience calling a fight though, Dean sucks as a ref and should be fired.
1bad65 04-25-2007, 05:21 PM Dean is hot/cold kind of ref. Sometimes he does a perfect job, like Sylvia/Mir and other times not so good, like the CroCop/Gonzaga fight. Dean also has fought MMA himself.
Ok I was watching this fight over and over cause I like to see a underdog like Gonzaga win but when Cro Cop went for the kick and Gonzaga took him down from there. Gonzaga was throwing elbow bombs on cro cop, winning the round with domination then when there is little time left the Ref (Herb Dean) stands both fighters up when Gonzaga was VERY busy on the ground. I've seen fights like Matt Hughes vs Chris Lytle where I think it was Herb Dean, Let Matt Hughes lay on top of Chris Lytle for a win. But Gonzaga was doing damage and still got stood up, u think dana/ref wanted cro cop to throw a KO kick?
You think Cro Cop is the new golden boy and Dana was helping him out for a win and title shot at Couture?? What you guys think about this? Has anyone else noticed?
lol, I noticed this also,and watching live I said to my mate "how ****ed up is that?" "poor Gonzaga was doing well"
I felt sorry for GG when they stood them up until I noticed how timid Mirko was, then BAM!
Atnan 04-25-2007, 10:56 PM i think he stood them up b/c the main event was on the ground for too long, and the good old american fans dont like the idea of it taking that long! :rofl:
Harms 04-26-2007, 12:28 AM i think he stood them up b/c the main event was on the ground for too long, and the good old american fans dont like the idea of it taking that long! :rofl:
Where you been man, haven't seen you around for awhile?
2swell k-wells 04-26-2007, 12:49 PM i think he stood them up b/c the main event was on the ground for too long, and the good old american fans dont like the idea of it taking that long! :rofl:
that is not a reason to stand fighters up. The Ref stands fighters if they aint doing nothing..for example Josh Koscheck lol. The ref always tells the fighters to "do something, or im gonna stand you up"
They dont think "oh the crowd aint gon like this" then stand them up hah.
2swell k-wells 04-26-2007, 12:49 PM or were ya kidding???:D
LoftyDog 04-26-2007, 06:03 PM Did the commentators say nething about the stand up? I don't remember them saying nething...which would make sense if White told them the same shit he told Herb lol
2swell k-wells 04-26-2007, 06:24 PM Did the commentators say nething about the stand up? I don't remember them saying nething...which would make sense if White told them the same shit he told Herb lol
no..but i thought Joe Rogan would say something because he always speaks play by play action.
In the past Joe Rogan also points out that if he(fighter) dont keep busy the Referee will stand them up...but Joe didnt say a thing when they got stood up..pretty stupid, but if he did mention the uncalled for standup then more peeps would be talking about it.
Joe was talking at the time they got stood up, it sounded like Goldman said "oh thats a shame" but Joe and Randy were talking at the same time
Living Legend 04-27-2007, 01:52 PM It looked like to me, that he noticed Cro Cop was getting bashed by them elbows and looking kind of bad on the bottom so as soon as they got close enough to the fence he stood them up. It was like he already had it pre determined in his mind that Crop Cop would win standing up, so he stood them up, only to witness Cro Cop almost get his neck and leg broke with one kick...
2swell k-wells 04-27-2007, 01:54 PM It looked like to me, that he noticed Cro Cop was getting bashed by them elbows and looking kind of bad on the bottom so as soon as they got close enough to the fence he stood them up. It was like he already had it pre determined in his mind that Crop Cop would win standing up, so he stood them up, only to witness Cro Cop almost get his neck and leg broke with one kick...
yes..backfired, Dana white was thinking - FUUCCKKK!!
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
|