Deontay Wilder vs. Bermane Stiverne II: A Product of Chaos


By Cliff Rold

Few fans are all that excited. It’s not even clear the fighters are particularly pumped.

Regardless, the rematch between WBC heavyweight titlist Deontay Wilder and Bermane Stiverne is happening this weekend (Showtime, 9 PM EST/6 PM PST). Wilder won almost every round the first time around. He’s heavily favored to win again. With an assist from a positive test for banned substance that led to a cancelled clash with Alexander Povetkin along the way, Stiverne has fought only once since that loss in January 2015.

That was still enough to wind up in the WBC’s top contender spot.

On Monday, BoxingScene’s Keith Idec penned a piece where fight promoter Lou DiBella asked a logical question: “How do you fight one fight in two years against a guy that knocked you down and subsequently gets knocked out, and barely do anything, and you’re still the WBC mandatory?”

It would be a stronger question if one ignored the circumstances of their first fight. As noted by this scribe in a preview of that clash in 2015:

Deontay Wilder has risen through the ratings of the WBC by sheer numbers. A check of the most current WBC ratings at Heavyweight show that Wilder is undefeated against their top forty Heavyweights. 

That’s not a big deal.

It’s easy to be undefeated against the top forty guys in the WBC ratings when you haven’t fought any of them. That’s not a misprint.  Wilder is rated number one by the WBC and hasn’t faced one guy rated in the 39 slots below him.

Then again, Stiverne has only faced one current WBC top 40 himself (Arreola is currently their 13th rated Heavyweight and was higher when he fought Stiverne for the vacant belt last year).

Stiverne being the top rated contender with his inactivity isn’t an anomaly. It’s par for the course. The ratings that most influence the fights we see often read more like chaos theory than meritocracy. Heading into this weekend, looking at the four most recognized sanctioning bodies, being the heavyweight champion is an honor shared by three fighters.

wilder-stiverne (4)_1

Below them is a combined list of top ten contenders twenty-five fighters deep.

That’s right. Boxing’s heavyweight division has twenty-five top ten contenders. Drawing from the current ratings on their websites, here is a snapshot of the heavyweight division heading into this weekend. Titlists are noted by asterisk and, for clarification, the IBF ratings technically have a vacant number one spot now so the below notes the next ten names in order.


For those who would argue boxing creates an institutional barrier to entry for new fans, this picture of the heavyweight ratings provides a strong case. The organizations rarely rate each other’s titlist’s or we’d be looking at a pool of twenty-eight possible top ten heavyweights. Across the four sanctioning bodies, only Dillian Whyte is rated by all. He is noted in red while the other seven fighters rated by at least two are in bold.

Some of the names are almost stunning in their appearance while others are a practice in anonymity. Alexander Dimitrenko has won twice since being knocked out by Parker; one of those wins was against a fighter with a losing record. Fres Oquendo hasn’t had a fight, much less a win, since 2014 though there may still be some outstanding legal issues with the WBA.

Many fans and pundits long ago stopped taking the sanctioning body ratings seriously. They have instead turned to the ratings of various publications or press collectives. Here is a snapshot of what happens when the heavyweight division is filtered through those lenses. In this case, only Ring currently recognizes a champion, maintaining the lineal position of Tyson Fury. The lists below are straight 1-10 rankings.


In full disclosure, this author is a chair and contributor to the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board (TBRB) and believes the sport would be better off with less belts and stronger merit based ratings. Lists like these aren’t constrained by not rating titlists against each other; that’s a clear advantage in pursuit of clarity. Even here, agreement about the top ten heavyweights isn’t universal but one could argue they deliver a much clearer picture of the division’s best.

There are, in total, thirteen fighters listed in the press ratings above. There is unanimous agreement that Anthony Joshua is the division leader. Six fighters, all bolded in red, are rated across the board if in different places. Ironically, Whyte misses a clean sweep of both sanctioning body and press-based lists by way of omission from the British publication.

Only three fighters, bolded in black, appear in only one top ten.

It’s easy to want this to be the way we look at the divisions and just tune out the noise but the noise dictates too much of the rest of what goes on. There are economic and structural realities that can’t be ignored.

Even if we ignore them, it does nothing to eliminate the disappointment many fans express when they get a Wilder-Stiverne II. What has to be recognized is that their disappointment is a byproduct of the chaos. In defense of the fight, it was supposed to be the far more tantalizing Wilder-Luis Ortiz but Ortiz failed a pre-fight drug test for a banned substance. When that fight fell apart, it left Wilder with a mandatory to fulfill.

It left Stiverne.

One could say, “he should just give up his belt,” but that same belt was attained through the chaotic sanctioning body system that had Wilder as a number one contender without a top forty win in the first place. His purses, exposure, and indeed his regard on more objective ratings lists all rose from the Stiverne fight forward.

Winning the WBC belt was good for him. Boxing’s ratings might not reflect pure merit, but those belts retain valuable economic cache.

As long as that’s true, then looking for logical answers about so many of the ratings that matter to fighters and their camps will remain an exercise in frustration.

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by boliodogs on 11-03-2017

What a great article by Cliff Rold. I agree with everything he said.It's amazing how different the rankings of the WBA, WBC, WBO and IBF are. A guy like Stiverne can be ranked 1st by the WBC and unranked by…

Comment by Ray* on 11-02-2017

[QUOTE=Randall Cunning;18179643]Its not now, articles questioning how Wilder first got a shot at the title, saying how did he get to number 1 contender without fighting a top 40 at the time. Articles more about how people manage to get…

Comment by DramaShow on 11-02-2017

'product of chaos' lol, it was the plan all along. a well executed plan is the opposite of chaos.

Comment by juggernaut666 on 11-02-2017

[QUOTE=Ray*;18179499]This is why my level of excitement for a Joshua/Wilder fight is just meh. He (Wilder) hasn't fought anyone to build that anticipation up, yeah he wants the Joshua fight no doubt, but most of the HW also want the…

Comment by Randall Cunning on 11-02-2017

How does the WBC come to the decision 6 vs 12 should be a final eliminator without some kind of outside influence

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (27)
Top Headlines Diego De La Hoya vs. Jose Salgado - Golden Boy on ESPN, Dec. 14 Bellew: It's Disgusting That Wilder Insinuated Joshua is on Steroids UK News: Tommy McCarthy, Lewis Crocker, Ricky Summers Miguel Cotto Career Special on HBO, November 25 Photo: Carl Frampton, Horacio Garcia Ready For War in Belfast Joseph Parker: I Have 'A Lot of Options' Other Than Joshua, Wilder Frampton: All The Big Fights Interest Me, The Best is Yet To Come Shawn Porter: Crawford Beats Horn Easy, Everybody is a Target! Teddy Atlas Explains Why He Favors Lomachenko Over Rigondeaux Ishe Smith: I Asked For Julian Williams, Confident I'll Get The Win Nathan Gorman Welcomes Daniel Dubois: He Knows Where I Am Alexander Povetkin vs. Christian Hammer - Full Card is Set Truax: I Have To Be at My Absolute Best To Beat James DeGale Jarrell Miller: I Would Stop Dillian Whyte in Four or Five Rounds Ryoichi Taguchi vs. Milan Melindo Unification Set, December 31 Wilder Would Agree to Fight Ortiz Again, Wants to 'Punish' Him Kovalev: The Pressure Will Be High To Fight Beterbiev, Bivol Roy Jones Jr. Brings WinnaVegas Casino Card To BeIN Sports Jamie Conlan Plans To Box Jerwin Ancajas, Not Go To War Jose Martinez Stops Jesus Martinez for NABO Championship Parker Says Forget Wilder Fight: I'm Knocking Anthony Joshua Out! Vasyl Lomachenko: The Fight With Rigondeaux Will Be Historic Kellerman on De La Hoya-McGregor: It's Amazing Conor is Favored Photo: Giovani Santillan, Dodzi Kemeh Ready For Battle Photos: Anthony Dirrell, Denis Douglin - Nearly Brawl at Weighin Canelo-Golovkin Rematch: Update on Negotiations, Date, Venue Jarrell Miller: Muscles Won't Save Joshua - He Has a Glass Jaw Ferdie Pacheco - "The Fight Doctor" - Passes Away at 89 Naoya Inoue vs. Yoan Boyeaux on December 30 Artur Beterbiev, Sergey Kovalev Eager To Settle Their Old Dispute Roach: Jose Ramirez Will Take Amir Imam's Heart, Knock Him Out Bellew: Parker Aiming For 40% For Joshua is Absolutely Ridiculous David Lemieux: One Month Until Ugly Saunders Gets Destroyed! News: Kai Robin Havnaa, Jason Welborn, Jono Carroll, More Arum, Crawford Waiting to Discuss Fighting Horn in Australia Miguel Cotto vs. Sadam Ali - Undercard Information Danny Gonzalez vs. Danny O'Connor For WBC Regional Belt Wilder To Joshua: I'm The Man That's Going To End Your Career! Carl Frampton Aims To Get Knockout Win Over Garcia Julian Williams: The Goal is To Be The First To KO Ishe Smith!

Latest Active Forum Threads