Advertisement
Advertisement

Dawson-Hopkins Recap: This Time, Maybe They’re Right

By Lyle Fitzsimmons

I’ve got to admit, this one even got to me.

Though I’ve heard it each time for years when my beloved boxing has had one of those nights, not one time have I ever thought, “You know, maybe all these people are on to something.”

Not when Fan Man crashed Bowe-Holyfield.

Not when Tyson gobbled Evander’s earlobes.

Not when Kermit Cintron tumbled to a ridiculous scorecard loss.

And not when Floyd Mayweather knocked Victor Ortiz loopy.

The death knell was sounded – in some places louder than others – after each of those events and several more, but I’ve never been one to give it much thought.

In good times or bad, some folks hate boxing. It’s a fact of life. And those of us who love the sport have learned to ignore the persistent din.

I get it. The prospect of two guys getting into a ring with shoes, trunks, gloves and a goal of inflicting damage on each other isn’t everyone’s cup of tea.

Some prefer more tepid pursuits like golf or tennis.

Others would lose the shoes and put the whole thing in a cage. And there’s always the contrarian bunch who’ll revel in up, left and white when the inarguable stands are down, right and black.

Perhaps it’s a lesson learned from gridlocked genius in Washington.

But regardless of origin, it’s nothing I take too seriously.

Or at least I didn’t until Saturday.

This time, after another several weeks of anticipatory build-up, another anticlimactic five minutes in the ring and another predictable “I’m the real champ/No, you’re not” press conference, I’m feeling a little less like being tied to the whipping post – thank you, Gregg Allman – once again.

And somehow, when a non-boxing fan uses the word “pathetic” to describe what went on around the main event at Staples Center, it’s sort of hard not to just nod in agreement.

Because this time, regardless of the big picture side you choose… it really was.

Whether you believe the aborted two rounds proved Chad Dawson was clearly superior or showed he had no chance to win, it’s impossible to contend the decisive sequence of right hand-takedown-ambulance was in any way a boon for the sport’s greater good.

And while Pat Russell’s “no foul” assessment can be excused in the heat of the moment, the idea that the night could ultimately end without cooler, smarter heads coming to a discernable conclusion shows just how close to correct the “pathetic” assessment might be.

An instant of thought from a moron like me yields a small handful of options superior to what George Dodd and the California State Athletic Commission – a pay grade or two above mine, to be sure – came up with when called upon, which was nothing.

Oh, I don’t know, let’s see… might I suggest looking at a replay or two?

Perhaps giving Hopkins five legitimate minutes to recuperate and choose his course?

Or allowing more than a few chaotic seconds of suit-and-tie consult before ringing the bell?

Though I’ve spent years chronicling the dramas, characters and heart-warming redemptions that dwarf any others, the boxing shortcomings revealed on nights like Saturday are unfortunately just as pedestal-worthy when compared to other sports.

After all the football and baseball games I’ve seen, I can’t imagine an officials’ huddle at the Super Bowl or an umpires’ meeting at the World Series ending with, “We really can’t tell if that last field goal/home run was legit or not, so we’re just going to end the game here and decide later.

“As of right now, at least, the Packers/Cardinals win.”

But in boxing, it’s not just imaginable. It’s routine.

Let’s face it, even if no real remedy was possible Saturday, perhaps something short of whisking Russell from the building would have left something better than a “Wow, these guys are idiots” taste in the mouths of casual fans who’ll think twice before again taking it seriously with a $55 price tag.

And the more I think about it… maybe they have it right.

As long as broadcasts end and stadiums empty in the wake of lingering nonsense like Dawson-Hopkins, then breathtaking finishes like DeMarco-Linares and resurrections like Dewey Bozella won’t be enough to claim space come Monday when those same casual fans gather to discuss the weekend.

And ultimately, big-stage flops won’t get the same big-stage chance to disappoint, because no one will care enough about them to begin with.

Sorry, George… but you sure didn’t make things any easier on an already ugly stepchild.  

Anyone for tennis?

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

This week’s title-fight schedule:

FRIDAY
WBC flyweight title – Bangkok, Thailand
Pongsaklek Wonjongkam (champion) vs. Edgar Sosa (No. 1 contender)
      
Wonjongkam (82-3-1, 45 KO): Third title defense; Held WBC title from 2001-07 (17 defenses)
Sosa (43-6, 26 KO): Thirteenth title fight (11-1, 7 KO); Held 108-pound title from 2007-09 (10 defenses)
Fitzbitz says: “Veteran flyweight king fends off smaller man’s challenge.” Wonjongkam by decision
 
SATURDAY
WBC/WBO bantamweight title – New York, N.Y.
Nonito Donaire (WBC/WBO champion) vs. Omar Narvaez (unranked)
      
Donaire (26-1, 18 KO): First title defenses; Held IBF/IBO flyweight titles from 2007-09 (three defenses)
Narvaez (35-0-2, 19 KO): Twenty-second title fight (20-0-1, 8 KO); Reigning WBO champ at 115 pounds
Fitzbitz says: “Little champ not enough to topple rising Filipino star.” Donaire in 10
 
WBO junior heavyweight title – Ludwigsburg, Germany
Marco Huck (champion) vs. Rogelio Rossi (No. 15 contender)
      
Huck (33-1, 24 KO): Eighth title defense; Unbeaten since 2007 (14-0, 10 KO)
Rossi (17-2-1, 11 KO): First title fight; First fight outside Argentina 
Fitzbitz says: “He may not be the world’s best cruiser, but he’s the best in this fight.” Huck in 9
 
MONDAY
WBA minimum title – Tokyo, Japan
Pornsawan Porpramook (champion) vs. Akira Yaegashi (No. 4 contender)
      
Porpramook (23-3-1, 16 KO): First title defense; First fight in Japan
Yaegashi (14-2, 7 KO): Second title fight (0-1, 0 KO); Tenth fight at venue (8-1, 3 KO)
Fitzbitz says: “Now that he’s got a title, he won’t give it up this quickly.” Porpramook by decision

NOTE: Fights previewed are only those involving a sanctioning body's full- fledged title-holder – no interim, diamond, silver, etc. Fights for WBA “world championships” are only included if no “super champion” exists in the weight class.

Last week's picks: 2-1
Overall picks record: 251-85 (74.7 percent)

Lyle Fitzsimmons has covered professional boxing since 1995 and written a weekly column for Boxing Scene since 2008. He is a full voting member of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Reach him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter – @fitzbitz.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Margarito_619 on 10-19-2011

You all have valid point...but i'm just tired of all the BS ...especially when boxers fake injuries! I know it's a tough sport but people are also paying for PPV and betting on these fights. Anyway I didn' t mean…

Comment by New England on 10-18-2011

I'm usually calling for this guys boxing writers card to get burned but he's at least got something right boxing is scary bad when its bad 60 bucks for that? you've got to be kidding me. and as for the…

Comment by Yessum on 10-18-2011

[QUOTE=Margarito_619;11308518]I don't mean to be a dick but it's always the brothas that have to **** things up and bring the damn circus into the ring! We saw it with Hopkins vs Dawson.. seen it with Bradley vs Campbell...seen it…

Comment by Hamaru on 10-18-2011

[QUOTE=Margarito_619;11308518]I don't mean to be a dick but it's always the brothas that have to **** things up and bring the damn circus into the ring! We saw it with Hopkins vs Dawson.. seen it with Bradley vs Campbell...seen it…

Comment by StrangerInTown on 10-18-2011

It's quite hard to maintain a vision of the sport that is not cynical. When you hear a Dawson proclaim himself champ without having thrown a winning punch, it says more about the man then the game. If you think…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (9)
Top Headlines Marlon Tapales To Receive Hero's Welcome For Title Win Leo Santa Cruz vs. Carl Frampton: Ring the Damn Bell Amir Khan Aims For Danny Garcia Mandatory Shot in January Miguel Cotto Officially Passes on Marquez Over Weight Dispute Mikey Garcia: You're Going To See a Better Version of Me! Joseph Diaz: Liam Smith is a Very Tough Fight For Canelo Photos: Adonis Stevenson, Thomas Williams Size Up at Presser Carl Frampton: Everyone Expects Me To Lose, I'll Get The Upset! Dorticos To Shumenov: You Paper Champ, Stop Running Chicken Photos: Margarito, Alvarez Go Face To Face at Presser Video: Leo Santa Cruz Ready For War With Carl Frampton Amir Khan: Arum is Bitter, He's Scared To Do The Pacquiao Fight! Photos: Frampton, Leo Santa Cruz, Malignaggi, Garcia Workouts Photo: Kell Brook Embraces VADA Testing For Golovkin Shot Amnat Ruenroeng Vows To Get Olympic Gold For His Family Photos: Andre Ward Cheers on Kevin Durant, Team USA Czar Glazkov Still Recovering, Return is Possible in November Video: Golovkin's Coach on Terence Crawford, Kell Brook, More Leo Santa Cruz: If Dad Didn't Get Better, I May Have Pulled Out Lucas Browne Enters WBC's VADA Drug Testing Program Frankie Gavin vs. Sam Eggington Looms For October Clash Luke Campbell Focused, Aims To Do a Job on Argenis Mendez Otto Wallin Faces Osborne Machimana on September 10th Liam Walsh to meet Andrey Klimov in IBF final eliminator Leo Santa Cruz Fearful Frampton Won’t Come To Fight Saturday Loeffler on GGG-Brook: The Best at 147 Facing The Best at 160 Bradley Warns: Crawford Can Win, But Pacquiao is NO Postol HBO Sports Head: We Want To Match The Best Fights Possible Olympic Boxers, Now Without Headgear, Worry About Cuts Dimitrenko Confident of Beating Parker, Derailing Joshua Fight Marlon Tapales Shocks Pungluang Sor Singyu, Wins WBO Belt Paul Smith Set For September Return, Won't Be on Liverpool Bill Abel Sanchez: Manny Pacquiao Should Fight Keith Thurman Photos: Robert Guerrero, Alfredo Angulo, Gausha Presser Paulie Malignaggi’s Master Plan: This is Just Step One Loeffler: Golovkin Will Have 3 Fights Prior To Canelo Fight Alfredo Angulo Eyes Gold: I Want a World Title Shot in 2017! Video: Timothy Bradley Talks Pacquiao vs. Crawford, More Video: Loeffler Talks Golovkin vs. Brook HBO Tripleheader Robert Guerrero Aims For Rematch With Danny Garcia
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement