BScene Staff Predictions: Arreola vs. Mitchell Clash

By Jake Donovan

No matter how meager the division is in present state, the old mantra holds true – anytime you have a chance to make a good heavyweight matchup, you go ahead and do it.

That leads us to Chris Arreola and Seth Mitchell squaring off tonight at the Fantasy Springs Casino in Indio, California. The Showtime-televised headliner pits two heavyweights in need of a big win to return to relevance in what still remains a wide open division beyond the top two spots.

Mitchell reversed the lone loss of his career, overcoming a knockout at the hands of Johnathon Banks to soundly outpoint the Detroit-based boxer this past June. Yet the win hardly sat well with boxing fans, who were utterly bored with the lack of action and who remain unconvinced that the former college football linebacker has what it takes to make a run in the heavyweight sweepstakes.

Arreola is coming off of a humiliating points loss at the hands of Bermane Stiverne. The Californian had won seven straight prior to that point, albeit against largely mediocre competition. Still, punching power like his gives him a fighting chance on any given fight night.

Read on to see how the staff at believes this weekend’s heavyweight fight plays out.


“I like Chris Arreola to stop Mitchell, even if it is the start of football season and the former linebacker is sure to be amped up for the occasion.”

- Mitch Abramson (Arreola TKO6)

“Arreola is better than Mitchell in just about every category and appears to finally have taken his training seriously. I think Arreola jumps on Mitchell early.”

- Ryan Burton (Arreola KO3)

“The Californian may hit the deck early on, he may look on the brink as well, but he should be able to withstand Mitchell's attacks and take advantage of his opponent's recent wobbles to secure a stoppage win.”

- Terence Dooley (Arreola KO between 6-8)

“Bombs away for however long it lasts, but Arreola shakes off modest incoming to tear through Mitchell and stop him inside of three rounds in a performance reminiscent of his demolition of Chazz Witherspoon (minus the disqualification ending).”

- Jake Donovan (Arreola KO3)

“Arreola went away to camp to get away from everything he knows distracts him and from all indications this is the Arreola who a lot of people expected to see when he first burst onto the scene.  I do think there will be times when he might get careless ala the Travis Walker fight but if he endures then he will overcome Mitchell.”

- Ernie Gabion (Arreola TKO4)

“For all of Arreola's limits, and despite the fact that he will never show up in the kind of shape that Seth Mitchell does, he has been battle-tested and can take a punch. Mitchell, for all of his athleticism, power and commitment to becoming a better boxer, still has the question mark that is his chin hanging over his head — or in this case, at the bottom of it. Unless Arreola's been irreversibly damaged by all the damage he's taken, I see him overcoming a tough moment or two and recovering, then cracking Mitchell, who will try to overcome the tough moments himself but won't be able to recover.”

- David Greisman (Arreola by TKO)

“Off the bat I favored Mitchell. I figured he would outlast and out work Arreola but that was before realizing this was a rededicated Arreola. Arreola switched camps to AZ for lessen distractions. Also he looks like he is in the best shape of his career.”

- Timothy Kudgis (Arreola TKO7)

“Chris Arreola was floored and outboxed by Bermane Stiverne in his last fight.  But while Mitchell has an excellent work ethic and showed his heart and resiliency in his rematch with Johnathon Banks, I feel that Arreola will have enough power and experience to stop him.”

- Ryan Maquinana (Arreola TKO6)

“Arreola required a lot of rebuilding after his losses to Vitali and Adamek. 3 years of rebuilding.  Then he lost.  The fragile rebuilding process is over, and now he just needs to get in there and fight like the contender he's been for years.  Mitchell came back immediately from his first loss and got redemption.  Arreola may have better overall skills, but Mitchell has proved to be much less fragile.  That should win in the heavyweight contender ranks every day.”

- Richard Najdowski (Mitchell by unanimous decision)

“One guy appears to have questionable whiskers.  The other has had questionable professionalism and a level of attention far outstripping a career that has gone on about a decade without a single win of any real note.  Mitchell appears the fare Arreola typically feasts on.  There's no reason to consider either guy a serious contender regardless of outcome, but it might make for a fun short fight before Arreola lowers the boom.”

- Cliff Rold (Arreola by knockout)

“Arreola-Mitchell will be fun while it lasts. I was ringside for Mitchell's last fight against Jonathan Banks in Brooklyn, NY and Mitchell looked hurt anytime Banks landed a punch to his chin. Banks reportedly hurt both hands during the fight, which may explain him rarely throwing any more punches in the fight. I wouldn't be surprised if Mitchell scores a flash knockdown, as Travis Walker did a couple of years ago. However, we all know what happened after that. I would be surprised if this fight goes past 6-7 rounds, but Arreola will be the one with his hand raised after the fight.”

- Francisco Salazar (Arreola by knockout)

“A fun match up that will end with Arreola putting his career back on track and stopping Mitchell at the half way point of the fight. Mitchell however won't go quietly into the night as I believe he will stun Arreola with his own power early on. But in the end, I think Mitchell's chin will let him down once again when Arreola lands his big punch. Arreola is the better technical fighter of the two and is motivated to not have back to back losses. He has a better chin and has fought the better opposition.”

- Luis Sandoval (Arreola TKO7)

“I don't have much faith in Mitchell. Specifically in his chin, which doesn't hold up at the highest level. He was wobbled badly in his second fight with Banks and against Witherspoon too. Those bouts are sandwiching his only (and crushing loss). On the other hand, Arreola was clipped hard and dropped at times but he has always found something to get up and fight on. It is said that Mitchell has a better chance of landing a huge haymaker and knocking Arreola down, and it's correct. But it's also true that despite having a smaller chance of connecting with something big, Arreola has a better chance of knocking Mitchell out.”

- Alexey Sukachev (Arreola TKO5)

Totals: Chris Arreola 12, Seth Mitchell 1

The heavyweight fight between Chris Arreola and Seth Mitchell airs live on Showtime from Fantasy Springs Casino in Indio, California.

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of Transnational Boxing Ratings Board, Yahoo Boxing Ratings Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by ADP02 on 09-08-2013

[QUOTE=Gudfella;13720745]I jus got up to turn off the lights in my room...nd mitchells lights were out b4 I sat back down [SIZE="1"][I]Posted from App for Android[/I][/SIZE][/QUOTE] That was the difference ..... Seth just can't handle a punch nor can…

Comment by Gudfella on 09-07-2013

I jus got up to turn off the lights in my room...nd mitchells lights were out b4 I sat back down [SIZE="1"][I]Posted from App for Android[/I][/SIZE]

Comment by torosboxing75 on 09-07-2013

I told you!!!!!

Comment by torosboxing75 on 09-07-2013

[QUOTE=Rapid8Fire;13719926]Wow..experts huh. Seth clearly has the better skill imo. All Arreola has is chin. Yall are in for a rude awakening tonight. Idk about Mitchell vs Wilder..Wilder is a freaking beast.[/QUOTE] And your going to be disappointed

Comment by torosboxing75 on 09-07-2013

[QUOTE=tdub2222;13719925]SETHS GOT THIS!!! i been waiting forever for this fight but the time is nearing!!! seth bout to put this clown away for good!!!:boxing:[/QUOTE] Your going to be disappointed

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (13)
Top Headlines Taras Shelestyuk Aims To Follow Gold Path of His Olympic Mates Brandon Rios a Free Agent, No Longer a Top Rank Fighter Katie Taylor Mulling Pro Move, Heading To Eddie Hearn? Fenech: Mundine-Green II is Bullsh*t Fight - Must Be Stopped! Nonito Donaire: I Want The Frampton vs. Santa Cruz Winner Next! Jack Doesn’t Take Much From DeGale’s Tough Fight with Medina Joshua's Fight Will Land on Showtime - Price, Jennings or Molina Keith Thurman vs. Danny Garcia Could Air on CBS in Prime Time George Foreman: Joshua Could Be Become an All-Time Great Andy Lee Wants Tough Fight, Gennady Golovkin Showdown Carl Frampton: I'll Beat Leo Santa Cruz Even More Convincingly! Jack: DeGale is Very Tough, I’ll Win and Be Best at 168 Arthur Abraham Out Of Martin Murray Rematch In Monte Carlo Craig Cunningham Heading To 154 After Shocker Over Ogogo Photos: Juanma Grinds Hard For Wilfredo Vazquez Grudge Fight Denis Shafikov vs. Richard Commey Set, Heading To Russia Broner vs. Granados on Feb. 11, Thurman vs. Garcia on March 4 Badou Jack vs. James DeGale Unification Set For January 14 Hosea Burton vs. Frank Buglioni Lands on Anthony Joshua Card Claressa Shields Pro Debut Finalized For Kovalev vs. Ward PPV Payano Eyes December Return in Quest For Second Title Reign Jason Sosa Embraces Smith Defense, Eyes Three Fights in 2017 Arum Apologizes To King For Post-Presidential Debate Vegas Spat Felix Verdejo is Very Eager To Get His Hands on Terry Flanagan Bob Arum on The Possibility of Miguel Cotto vs. Timothy Bradley Abel Sanchez: Ponamarev Likely Back on Lomachenko vs. Walters Bryant Jennings Ready To Step In, Face Anthony Joshua on 12/10 Dereck Chisora: Dillian Whyte is Nothing - I Will Stop Him! Vernon Forrest - Third Man Has Been Convicted in His Murder Pacquiao Feels Brunt of Long Flight, Takes Off From Training Marquez: If Canelo Trades With Golovkin - He's Committing Suicide! Lucas Browne Finds Himself in Limbo After Klitschko's Injury Andre Ward Aims To Set The Record Straight With Sergey Kovalev Video: Joe Smith Jr. Very Pumped To Face Bernard Hopkins Haye Explains Why Anthony Joshua-Eric Molina is Next - Not Price Marrero vs. Zambrano Talks Progress As Purse Bid Looms Klitschko's Manager Says Unfinished Contract Led To 2017 Jump Video: Oscar De La Hoya on Schaefer's Return, Hopkins, More Photos: Bernard Hopkins, Joe Smith Jr. - Face To Face at Presser Anthony Mundine, Danny Green Rematch Set For February 3

Latest Active Forum Threads