BoxingScene Staff Predictions: Nonito Donaire-Jorge Arce

By Jake Donovan

Normally, a result like the one that occurred last Saturday in Las Vegas would leave an anti-climactic feel to the remainder of the boxing year. From the moment Juan Manuel Marquez saw his final right hand crash down on Manny Pacquiao’s jaw, the initial reaction was how to properly commemorate the event come year-end awards time.

Round of the Year for their two-way action in round five? It’s possible.

Fight and Knockout of the Year? The talks have already suggested runaway favorites.

Fighter of the Year to Marquez?

Not so fast. Knocking out one Filipino superstar doesn’t remove all from the running.

Nonito Donaire hopes to cap what been an incredible 2012 campaign when he faces Jorge Arce in a world 122 lb. championship title defense. The bout takes place Saturday evening at the Toyota Center in Houston, Texas. HBO will air the bout, marking Donaire’s fourth appearance on the network this year, all of which will have come against consensus Top 10 competition.

If you ask the experts, then an Arce win would perhaps headline another year-end category, Upset of the Year. Read on to see how the staff believe the action will unfold and the Fighter of the Year race will turn out.


“Donaire is Fighter of the Year hands down if he beats Arce.  He will have overwhelmingly beat four contenders in one year.  His skills are at another level than anyone else's.”

- Damien Acevedo (Donaire // Donaire for Fighter of the Year)

“Arce is always all heart, but this is a terrible matchup of styles for him. His lone shot is a puncher’s chance, which is never much of a chance at all when your opponent boasts a granite chin. Donaire is too good across the board. Donaire by mid-round stoppage to win tonight, and then again in another 2½ weeks when he is declared Fighter of the Year."

– Jake Donovan (Donaire // Donaire for Fighter of the Year)

“Donaire TKO6. I think the Nonito we saw in the Nishioka fight is more indicative of what we will see in the ring than the Mathebula fight.  Arce will make it fun while it lasts but he will fall far short of the mark. He is still my Figther Of The Year because while JMM has the more emphatic victory he still has only one good win to hang his hat on. The Fedechenko fight was abysmal and he was arguably losing the Pacquiao fight as well.”

– Ernest Gabion (Donaire // Donaire for Fighter of the Year)

“Nonito Donaire KO5 Jorge Arce.  Much has been said about the involvement of Jorge Arce's strength coach, Angel Heredia Hernandez, in this fight.  However, compared to Hernandez's other charge Juan Manuel Marquez having previously established stylistic dilemmas against Manny Pacquiao, that is not the case here. I think Donaire lands a counter left hook to floor Arce, finishes 2012 a sparkling 4-0 in a brand new division, and solidifies his claim as Fighter of the Year.”

- Ryan Maquinana (Donaire // Donaire for Fighter of the Year)

“Donaire KO4 Arce.  Donaire will continue to make his case for fighter of the year, having spent all of 2012 dominating his new 122 lb. division.  Donaire has set himself apart from all top fighters by fighting 4 times year year, and he'll finish the year out with his 4th win and second consecutive knockout.  That'll be good enough for runner-up in the Fighter of the Year, because he did not have a game changing victory like JMM did last weekend in his 4th battle with the now slain Pac-Monster.  If Donaire gets a match with Abner Mares in 2013, he'll have his opportunity for a game changing victory.  If he gets Rigondeuax, too, and beats both of them, then the 2013 FOTY will be his.  Unless, of course, someone comes along and upsets Mayweather.”

- Richard Najdowski (Donaire // Marquez for Fighter of the Year)

“Donaire KO Arce: Remember the scene in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom when the villain pulled a beating heart out of a chest.  That's about what this fight chalks up to.  On paper, this is ritual slaughter.  Arce's career has been in a pattern for years.  He fights fun fights against B-sides and faded names he managed not to tempt when they were good, gets matched with a live top talent and loses, rinse and repeat.  WVII was an anomaly to that equation (and might not qualify as top talent) and a testament to his longevity but here he's smaller, slower, and facing a lethal puncher.  If it's competitive, that might be the Upset of the Year.  It's the perfect fight to make Donaire look like King Kong and if he's in the sort of zone he was for Wladimir Sidorenko and Fernando Montiel, this could be over anywhere from the first to the sixth.  There's a lot of talk that this fight, which would seal a 4-0 campaign for the year, also seals a Fighter of the Year bid for Donaire.  I'm not so sure.  Marquez's win over Pacquiao was so much larger in magnitude than anything Donaire has done this year, so much more newsworthy, that one shot made override four wins.  I view Marquez as the leader in the field right now.  Magnitude matters.”

– Cliff Rold (Donaire // Marquez for Fighter of the Year)

"Nonito Donaire TKO 6-8 Jorge Arce. Marquez aside, The Filipino Flash has a Fighter of the Year label written all over him. A win over "El Travieso", which in my mind is almost a done deal, can leapfrog the kid over the great Mexican to a prize, which is rightfully his. In order to do that Donaire should win in mildly emphatic fashion, which means he needs a stoppage or a landslide on the cards. He has an ability to do that: the Pinoy wonder is bigger, faster and younger than Arce, whose numerous recent titles don't fully reflect the decrease in his abilities. The clash will be hot-contested with Arce having his share of success early, but Nonito's skills will frustrate Arce, and his punching power will force a Darchinyan-like stoppage or retirement somewhere after the midpoint."

- Alexey Sukachev (Donaire // Donaire For Fighter of the Year)

Total - Fight: Nonito Donaire 7, Jorge Arce 0

Total – Fighter of the Year Race: Donaire (with a win tonight) 5, Marquez 2

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of Follow Jake on Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Post a Comment - View More User Comments (0)
Top Headlines Fenech: Mundine-Green II is Bullsh*t Fight - Must Be Stopped! Nonito Donaire: I Want The Frampton vs. Santa Cruz Winner Next! Jack Doesn’t Take Much From DeGale’s Tough Fight with Medina Joshua's Fight Will Land on Showtime - Price, Jennings or Molina Keith Thurman vs. Danny Garcia Could Air on CBS in Prime Time George Foreman: Joshua Could Be Become an All-Time Great Andy Lee Wants Tough Fight, Gennady Golovkin Showdown Carl Frampton: I'll Beat Leo Santa Cruz Even More Convincingly! Jack: DeGale is Very Tough, I’ll Win and Be Best at 168 Arthur Abraham Out Of Martin Murray Rematch In Monte Carlo Craig Cunningham Heading To 154 After Shocker Over Ogogo Photos: Juanma Grinds Hard For Wilfredo Vazquez Grudge Fight Denis Shafikov vs. Richard Commey Set, Heading To Russia Broner vs. Granados on Feb. 11, Thurman vs. Garcia on March 4 Badou Jack vs. James DeGale Unification Set For January 14 Hosea Burton vs. Frank Buglioni Lands on Anthony Joshua Card Claressa Shields Pro Debut Finalized For Kovalev vs. Ward PPV Payano Eyes December Return in Quest For Second Title Reign Jason Sosa Embraces Smith Defense, Eyes Three Fights in 2017 Arum Apologizes To King For Post-Presidential Debate Vegas Spat Felix Verdejo is Very Eager To Get His Hands on Terry Flanagan Bob Arum on The Possibility of Miguel Cotto vs. Timothy Bradley Abel Sanchez: Ponamarev Likely Back on Lomachenko vs. Walters Bryant Jennings Ready To Step In, Face Anthony Joshua on 12/10 Dereck Chisora: Dillian Whyte is Nothing - I Will Stop Him! Vernon Forrest - Third Man Has Been Convicted in His Murder Pacquiao Feels Brunt of Long Flight, Takes Off From Training Marquez: If Canelo Trades With Golovkin - He's Committing Suicide! Lucas Browne Finds Himself in Limbo After Klitschko's Injury Andre Ward Aims To Set The Record Straight With Sergey Kovalev Video: Joe Smith Jr. Very Pumped To Face Bernard Hopkins Haye Explains Why Anthony Joshua-Eric Molina is Next - Not Price Marrero vs. Zambrano Talks Progress As Purse Bid Looms Klitschko's Manager Says Unfinished Contract Led To 2017 Jump Video: Oscar De La Hoya on Schaefer's Return, Hopkins, More Photos: Bernard Hopkins, Joe Smith Jr. - Face To Face at Presser Anthony Mundine, Danny Green Rematch Set For February 3 Video: Bernard Hopkins, Joe Smith - Go Face To Face Video: Bernard Hopkins Breaks Down Joe Smith Showdown Arum on Parker vs. Ruiz Possibly Heading To The United States

Latest Active Forum Threads