Billy Joe Saunders-David Lemieux: Post-Fight Report Card

by Cliff Rold

Roughly year ago, WBO middleweight titlist Billy Joe Saunders was taking a beating in some corners of boxing social media. He was fresh off a year long layoff, looked ho-hum against a largely unknown opponent, and was seen as relevant only insofar as he had the belt Gennady Golovkin didn’t have.

What a difference a year makes. What a difference a day makes.

Last Saturday, Saunders reminded everyone he had to be pretty good to beat Chris Eubank Jr. on the way up and Andy Lee for a belt. He had a case for shutting out David Lemieux in Lemieux’s backyard. Saunders disarmed the big punching artillery and boxed Lemieux’s ears off.

Now many of the same people giving Saunders grief not long ago are curious about what he might look like in the ring with Golovkin or a Canelo Alvarez. 

saunders-lemieux-fight (3)

Let’s go the report card.


Pre-Fight: Speed – Saunders B+; Lemieux B+/Post: B+; B

Pre-Fight: Power – Saunders B-; Lemieux A/Post: B;

Pre-Fight: Defense – Saunders B+; Lemieux B-/Post: A+; C-

Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Saunders B+; Lemieux B+/Post: A; C+

CompuBox is not a science and can often be shown quite inaccurate, if useful as an approximation. The numbers from this fight sure feel about right.

Saunders put on a defensive performance here that was on par with what can be expected of some of the best defenders in the game. According to Compubox, Lemieux threw close to 30 punches per round. He landed in double digits in only the eleventh round.

Saunders did that while throwing more and landing more than Lemieux. While not statistically accurate, many of Lemieux’s misses were intentional. Jabs that feel short to set up the southpaw left; looping rights and lefts to the gloves to keep his power-punching rival in his shell.

Lemieux complained after the fight about running. It was a hollow complaint. The only running Saunders did was run away with a win.

For Lemieux, he’s still only 28 and probably another run of well picked knockout victims from another title shot. Given his struggles to get to 160 lbs., a move up in weight might be a good idea.

For Saunders, the question of what’s next could be all about when a Golovkin-Alvarez rematch develops. If it’s in the first half of 2018, does that mean Saunders stays busy but not too dangerously so, waiting for the winner? If it’s not until the second half of the year, could Saunders slip in as the spring foe for either?

If Saunders and his team determine that there is guarantee of the big fight in 2018, or that another wait would be to their detriment, the HBO investment at middleweight could provide other options. Daniel Jacobs and Demetrius Andrade are world-class opponents under contract there. Jermall Charlo is also out there in the division and the Al Haymon affiliated badass is going to look for a title sooner than later.

Of those options, Jacobs and Charlo would both be exciting opponents who would test the defense and clever boxing of a Saunders. Saunders would be at a firepower deficit against both and they have skill to go with it. Andrade might be interesting technically but the combination of counter punchers could also make for a dreadful evening.

Of course they are all better options than where Saunders was between Lee and Lemieux. We already knew the kid could fight. Now that everyone is reminded, let’s see just how high the ceiling is.   

Report Card Picks 2017: 45-18

Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel, the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by crold1 on 12-20-2017

[QUOTE=mrbigshot;18350604]You’re right, the author is a cvnt who talks to people like **** when they have the audacity to question Holyfield’s standing as a hall of famer given the history with Evan fields and steroids But cliff roids can easily…

Comment by mrbigshot on 12-20-2017

[QUOTE=bronx7;18349102]Lemieux pre fight defense rating by inept writer B- a joke it should be D horrible GGG couldn’t miss power jab all night worse than Saunders did power A all other Lemieux scores D overated buuuuum[/QUOTE] You’re right, the author…

Comment by Tutsa on 12-20-2017

**** this whole company with all the excuses for there big L . I wasn't a huge fan of BJS before the fight cause he never devoted himself for the gift he was blessed with but now he has showed…

Comment by Shadoww702 on 12-20-2017

[QUOTE=bronx7;18349102]Lemieux pre fight defense rating by inept writer B- a joke it should be D horrible GGG couldn’t miss power jab all night worse than Saunders did power A all other Lemieux scores D overated buuuuum[/QUOTE] And then F for…

Comment by Ray* on 12-20-2017

[QUOTE=Superbee;18349175]He started his Pro career at 18 + 4 months...[/QUOTE] Wow maybe thats why i think he older than he is.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (8)
Top Headlines Horn's Promoter Warns: Crawford Will Regret Moving Up To 147! Beterbiev Looks Forward To Kovalev Bout, Denies Rejecting Him Video: Errol Spence Talks Peterson, Welterweight Division Video: Freddie Roach Talks Pacquiao-Lomachenko, Crawford Arum: Lomachenko's Father Must Approve 140 For Pacquiao Bout Crawford-Horn, Pacquiao-TBA is Fully Ruled Out For Las Vegas Gvozdyk vs. Amar For WBC Interim-Title on March 17, ESPN Lomachenko Voted in as BWAA 2017 "Fighter of The Year" Fortuna Fails to Make Weight Again; Easter's Title Not at Stake Photos: Browne vs. Ntetu, Kownacki vs. Kiladze - Official Weights Mikey Garcia vs. Sergey Lipinets Rescheduled To March 10 Photos: Robert Easter, Javier Fortuna - Ready For Fireworks Battle Photos: Errol Spence, Lamont Peterson - Ready For Barclays War O'Sullivan Hopes For Jacobs, Confident He'll KO Eubank in Rematch Murray Ready For Saunders: I Have One Legit Loss at 160 - GGG Jose Ramirez, Amir Imam Deal Reached Before Purse Bid Fortuna Blames Weather for Missing Weight for Easter Fight Hearn: If Tyson Fury Wants Joshua in The Summer - No Problem Ohara Davies Inks Pact With MTK, Very Apologetic Over Mishaps Horn's Promoter: I Hope Teddy Atlas NEVER Gets New Job On-Air! LIVE STREAM: Errol Spence vs. Lamont Peterson Official Weigh-In Kell Brook Eyes Khan, Hopes To Make Big Splash at 154-Pounds Paul Butler Back On Okolie vs. Chamberlain Card, Feb 3 In London Billy Joe Saunders vs. Martin Murray on April 14, O2 Arena Tyson Fury To Regain His License To Box From BBBoC Jamal James Reflects on KO of Chaves, Open To Face Jessie Vargas Easter: Lomachenko Wouldn't Beat Me; Don’t Think It'll Happen Spence: Thurman, Garcia, Porter Wouldn't Answer Call to Fight Me Browne: Whyte is Like Mundine - Sh*t Talks His Way Into Fights! Josh Taylor: I Think Humberto Soto is Tougher Fight Than Vazquez Gorman Feels Dubois Fight is "Bound To Happen Down The Line" Parker: Trash Talk Helped Make Fight, But I Feel I Can KO Joshua Filip Hrgovic vs. Tom Little Added To Usyk-Briedis Card Sanchez: GGG Couldn't Go To Body, Canelo Was Nearly Running! Can Spence Overpower Peterson, Demolish Him Way Matthysse Did? James DeGale To Trigger Rematch Clause With Caleb Truax Team Horn Embrace Fighting Terence Crawford at MSG in April Fortuna: No Excuses From Easter - The IBF Belt Will Come To DR Trainer: Spence is Hardest Puncher I've Seen - Breaks Faces, Ribs! Mijares Reacts To Berchelt, May Face Papito Vazquez on March 17

Latest Active Forum Threads