…But What If Maidana Wins?

by Cliff Rold

This weekend, like last weekend, appears to be all about the foregone conclusion.  In back to back weeks, fans will see the literal best fighter in the world (Heavyweight Champion Wladimir Klitschko) and the mythical pound-for-pound best fighter in the world (Welterweight and Jr. Middleweight Champion Floyd Mayweather.

Alex Lepai’s chances against Klitschko were none.  Marcos Maidana’s chances against Mayweather are slim.

Anyone seen slim in Vegas recently?

If slim hasn’t left town yet, it would be surprise if the car isn’t revved and waiting.

Maidana is a hard fighter not to be happy for.  He fights hard, makes great shows, and arrives at the reward for his hard way of doing things. 

Almost no one thinks he has a prayer.

In one of those ‘don’t bitch later’ moments boxing fans rarely cop to, there was loud public outcry for Maidana to be the selection over the other name bandied about: Amir Khan.  Let’s ignore that this was a phony choice from jump.

These were not the two best available fighters Mayweather could fight.

They were the two best available he would fight.

Khan, mostly inactive since a loss to Danny Garcia, aggravated some with an attitude of entitlement about a Mayweather showdown.  He didn’t have the sort of emotionally resonant win that Maidana did over Adrien Broner.

In the ring, Khan would have been an underdog to Mayweather just like Maidana is.  Based on physical attributes and skill sets, he also would have had a relatively better chance at the upset.  Fans who are disappointed by the ease with which Mayweather likely defeats Maidana might forget that they howled at the more competitive fight on paper.

Don’t let them.


…what if this line of thinking is all wrong?  Maidana might be a huge underdog, but he’s no Lepai.  He’s a legitimate top ten Welterweight, a reigning beltholder, and he’s faced a slew of top names.  Only one man, Devon Alexander, has defeated him without any debate at the end.  Fighters of superior speed and athleticism like Broner, Ortiz, and Khan (who eked out a win over Maidana in 2010) have had their hands full with Maidana before.

Mayweather is 37 and while this era seems to have more fighters lasting longer, 37 is still getting up there for a fighter. 

There are many who see technical improvement in Maidana since the loss to Alexander.

Is the recipe there for an upset?

Probably not but…

…what if Maidana wins?

It’s an intriguing question and one whose answer, if the upset occurs, opens up a slew of additional questions about the immediate future of boxing.

Questions like…

Would There Be a Rematch?

One assumes Mayweather has an airtight rematch clause for any fight.  If Maidana upsets him, he’ll be able to pull that card right away.  This isn’t the rematch clause from Broner-Maidana.  There is no bigger name to make it go away.  In a loss, Mayweather might be an even hotter economic commodity for at least one fight.  Recall that, after Evander Holyfield upset Mike Tyson in 1996, their 1997 fight was even bigger.  Maidana, with a win, would become a folk hero in his native Argentina and with the masses long hoping for Mayweather’s Waterloo.  The logical monetary answer is of course there would be a rematch.

What if logic doesn’t count?  Mayweather has put so much public stock over the years in his undefeated mark.  Given his age, and recently stated musings about retirement, would a defeated Mayweather want to continue on?  The clearest path to victory for Maidana is either a knockout of sustained beating.  Mayweather is already penciled in for a September date.  If a Maidana victory took that form, would that be enough recovery time for him?

Would This Instantly End Chatter About Mayweather-Hopkins?

Mayweather-Bernard Hopkins seems to be a growing whisper campaign.  It would make a lot of money.  It would make interesting press conferences and All Access infomercials.  It would probably be a grind to watch.  The allure of that fight would come, as Hopkins has stated, from a build centered on Mayweather’s road to 50-0 versus a Hopkins who would be 50.  Take that away and does the chatter go with it?

Would This Change the Game Board at Golden Boy?

Headlines are plenty covering the dispute between Oscar De La Hoya and Richard Schaefer over control of Golden Boy Promotions.  Schaefer’s relationship with Mayweather gives him a powerful chip.  Mayweather isn’t as Golden Boy fighter but he uses them as a proxy through Schaefer.  If Mayweather loses this Saturday, even if he won a rematch, the future becomes much closer to now.  After Mayweather and Pacquiao, the biggest pay-per-view vehicle in boxing right now is probably Canelo Alvarez and Alvarez is signed to Golden Boy.  Canelo might have a loss to Mayweather but, only in his 20s, he also has time on his side.  Alvarez has a huge test to get through this summer in Erislandy Lara.  If he gets past it in the aftermath of a Mayweather loss, game on.

Would This Change the Looming Pacquiao Story?

Quietly, what could be the biggest business-side story of 2014 is emerging.  Manny Pacquiao is reportedly being offered a four-fight extension by Top Rank with one fight still committed on his current deal.  If Pacquiao rides out that last fight without signing an extension, he’ll be the biggest free agent in boxing in a long time; much bigger than Miguel Cotto was a few years ago.  If Mayweather wins as expected this weekend, and wins against whomever should he fight in September AND if Pacquiao wins the last fight on his Top Rank deal without extending, we all know what’s coming.  The volume will be as high as it’s been since late 2009/early 2010 for the only showdown everyone has ever really wanted to see.  Given the amount of money the fight could generate, Pacquiao would be insane not to wait and explore his options.

If Maidana wins, would there still be an incentive to wait or does that push the extension and whatever guarantees it provides into a stronger position?  Would Pacquiao wait to see what happens with a possible Maidana-Mayweather rematch?  History says a loss can sometimes force men to a table.  Lennox Lewis and Mike Tyson circled each other for years but, after Lewis split fights with the unexpected Hasim Rahman, they quit circling and made sure they cashed in.          

Floyd Mayweather is going to win this weekend.

But if he doesn’t…      
Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by handsome1-1 on 05-03-2014

PAC can easily take that "0" and Floyd knows it.

Comment by Emon723 on 05-03-2014

I've been thinking all day long of a scenario if Maidana wins, Mayweather will either call for a rematch or walk away, "little brother" Broner gets more bitter, Maidana gives up the WBA belt and defend against Danny Garcia (who…

Comment by Jubei on 05-03-2014

I cant even imagine what would happen, this would be so unreal i cant even imagine what would happen. Boxingscene will be down due to insane traffic for a couple days and i actually think this would be huge for…

Comment by Det. Conan on 05-03-2014

[QUOTE=drenlou;14494873]Maidana aint the "ONE", to take floyds "0".[/QUOTE] Yeah! You are right my friend. He is not the one. Ofcourse Floyd will win, Everbody knows that. He'll put a Boxing clinic for Maidana in a very Boring way. Its not…

Comment by sicko on 05-03-2014

It would be an AMAZING UPSET and a Amazing Year for him! This is BOXING anything can happen any night at any time

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (49)
Top Headlines Ryan Martin Working With Abel Sanchez, Eyes December Return Why Arum Turned Down HBO PPV To Handle Pacquiao-Vargas Himself Vargas, in Victory, is Open To Face Anyone Next - Mayweather Too Schaefer: Canelo Beats Golovkin, I Would Have Already Made It! DiBella Forced To Withdraw Remaining 2016 NY Fight Dates Roach: Canelo-Cotto Rematch Will Happen Before Canelo-Golovkin Orlando Cruz Promises Historical Title Win Over Terry Flanagan Koncz: Manny Pacquiao is 100% Ready For Jessie Vargas Nicola Adams in Talks To Join Eddie Hearn's Matchroom Frank Warren Not Pleased With How Jamie Cox's Win Played Out Leo Santa Cruz Says Father's Illness Was a Factor in Frampton Loss Roach: Mayweather Will Fight Again, He's Looking For Pacquiao Pacquiao Credits His Discipline in Juggling Tough Schedule Orlando Cruz Vows To Beat Flanagan: I Will Be First Gay Champ! Video: Jesus Cuellar Very Eager To Finally Face Mares Roach Doubts Canelo is Serious About Cotto: He Won't Fight Us! Video: Abner Mares Discusses New Trainer, Cuellar Title Shot Crawford's Opponent in Place, Going To Contracts, Says Arum Video: Robert Garcia on Brandon Rios, Mares-Cuellar, More Pacquiao vs. Vargas: No Delay Broadcast of PPV, Says Arum Video: Richard Schaefer Talks Return, Mayweather, Canelo-GGG Roach: Golovkin May Need To Jump To 175 For More Recognition Photos: Cuellar, Mares Go Face To Face at Los Angeles Presser Parker's Promoter Withdraws Funding Bid For Andy Ruiz Bout DeGale Confident That He'll Beat, Expose Weaknesses in Golovkin Roach Admits: Crawford is NOT My Favorite Fight For Pacquiao Schaefer: I Couldn't Be Coming Back With a Better Fight Card Crawford To Face PBC Fighter Next? Then Pacquiao in 2017? Roach: Pacquiao is Too Big, Lomachenko is Not That Good Javier Fortuna vs. Omar Douglas Camp Notes Pacquiao vs. Lomachenko is The Fight Arum Wants To Make Most Terry Flanagan vs. Orlando Cruz on November 26, Motorpoint Roach: Golden Boy Protecting Their 'Cash Cow' From Golovkin John Molina Wants to Dethrone 140 Kingpin Terence Crawford Schaefer Explains Ringstar Business Model, PBC Relationship Roach Still Wants Pacquiao vs. Canelo: I Love That Fight! Parker's Promoter Still Pushing To Keep Ruiz Fight in Auckland Manny Pacquiao: I Need a Convincing Win To Prove I'm Still Here Scott Quigg Makes Featherweight Debut on Anthony Joshua Card Pacquiao vs. Vargas Lands on BoxNation

Latest Active Forum Threads