Advertisement
Advertisement

A Rose, By Any Other Name… Still Doesn’t Deserve It

By Lyle Fitzsimmons

As a Cincinnati Reds fan, I’ve been saying it for 25 years.

Though he’s long been known for a loathsome personality, one Peter Edward Rose has more hits than anyone else who’s ever played major league baseball. Which means, without his plaque on the wall in the bucolic enclave of Cooperstown, N.Y., the National Baseball Hall of Fame is a fraud.

Meanwhile, just 69 miles northwest in the Syracuse suburb of Canastota, another such statement can be made about the home of stars in another sport. Though he had a career most would envy, if Arturo Gatti makes it onto the wall there next year, then the International Boxing Hall of Fame is an abject failure. 

And with apologies to election-season poll heads, “likeability factor” should have nothing to do it.

While Rose is by consensus a lying egomaniac with a bloated sense of self, his performance on the field is measurably as good as anyone who’s ever gripped a bat. It’s a stark contrast to Gatti, who admittedly thrilled a generation of wide-eyed fans, but fell flat – literally – against the best of his peers.

Rose – a rookie of the year, an MVP, a three-time batting champion and a 17-time all-star – has been barred from enshrinement for more than two decades by voting rules concocted to punish him for being defiant, rather than reverential, when it came to explaining off-field foibles.

At the same time, Gatti’s admirable accomplishments – five defenses of alphabet titles in two weight classes – are raised to legend by the Jersey Shore set because he tended to wobble and bleed a lot before rallying to beat fighters who’d never caught a whiff of a pound-for-pound list.

Whether or not you can stomach baseball, the comparison is valid. And if my fellow boxing voters lean on car-crash nostalgia rather than cold, hard logic, the symbolic blood on their keyboards will be as red as that which has caked under holier-than-thou major-league fingernails for two decades.

While the baseball case for Rose can be made with barely a glance at his body of work, the only way to justify “Thunder’s” inclusion in 2013 is by waxing poetic about ambiance in Atlantic City and holding séances in the flickering DVR glow of train wrecks with Micky Ward, Ivan Robinson and Gabriel Ruelas.

“But those were all named fights of the year,” the enraptured masses wail, mentioning neither that the foes were light years from elite, nor that Gatti actually lost two of the brawls. “And he was part of three rounds of the year,” they cry, though their hero, too, was a measly 1-for-3 in those fights.

Devotion, to them, apparently trumps disclosure.

No matter how it’s inspired, the induction dossier for Gatti hardly goes beyond a revisionist history recap of a run that was really big on highlights, really small on greatness. And once past the claims that Gatti was both an action fighter and very popular on his adopted home turf – neither of which is up for a vote, by the way – the “Arturopoligists” have precious little else with which to buttress their cases.  

Hey, don’t get me wrong. If all we’re talkin’ about here is a barroom nook to honor the greatest Italians to ever crack a few skulls in the Garden State, I concede my cohorts’ lingering man-crushes are enough for me to say “fuggedaboutit” to dissent.

But when it comes to halls of fame, there really ought to be something more, don’t you think?

Something more than never being undisputed? Something more than never being a pound-for-pounder? Something more than half of what Felix Sturm totaled in terms of title defenses?

And something more than sycophants simply insisting he had more heart, courage and guts than contemporaries, simply because he got hit a lot more and fell down twice as much?  

It’s the sort of popularity contest mentality that chips away at Canastota’s remaining relevance.

Whether he drew crowds of dozens or thousands and whether he played rooms in Jersey or Joliet, a fighter ought to be judged on his acumen, his accomplishments and the level of his adversaries. He needn’t have won every fight or looked good in every triumph, but at the end of the day, it should be a no-brainer that he meets the litmus test of “Was he one of his generation’s best?”

Take away dramatics against guys of his ilk, and the answer for Gatti is a resounding “Hell, no!”

He was only one of the best at 130 in the days of Nelson and Hernandez, and got pounded far below that depth when he wandered from the Branco/Dorin/Leija wading pool to the Mayweather Jr. deep end at 140 a few years later. A contrived resurgence at welter was a flop as well – save for a defeat of forgettable Dane Thomas Damgaard – and it ultimately ended not in a unification coronation, but with consecutive “somebody ought to stop this” losses to guys barely graduated from reality TV.

If you can find me a Hall-worthy stretch in any of that, I’d love to see it.

But in truth, he was a lot closer to 20-lap feature night at the local fairgrounds than the Indianapolis 500, and a lot nearer to Spider Rico than he ever got to “Italian Stallion.” And if he’d have ever actually tangled with the real-life likes of Apollo Creed, they’d have never needed a second movie.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

This week’s title-fight schedule:

SATURDAY
IBF/WBO junior featherweight titles – Carson, Calif.
Nonito Donaire (IBF/WBO champion) vs. Toshiaki Nishioka (No. 2 WBO contender)                        
Donaire (29-1, 18 KO): Second WBO title defense; Fourth fight above 118 (3-0, 1 KO)     
Nishioka (39-4-3, 24 KO): Twelfth title fight (7-2-2); Unbeaten above 118 since 1995 (27-0-1, 16 KO)        
Fitzbitz says: “Donaire has battered a pair at 122 but couldn’t finish either one. Faced with a slugger who’s been near the division’s top for years, expect another struggle – but a win.” Donaire by decision

Lyle Fitzsimmons has covered professional boxing since 1995 and written a weekly column for Boxing Scene since 2008. He is a full voting member of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Reach him at [email protected] or follow him on Twitter – @fitzbitz.

Tags:
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Chuckguy on 10-12-2012

Well if Gatti makes it in then so should the following Mikey Ward Ike Quartay Azumah Nelson Antonio Margarito Vernon Forrest Fernando Vargas Roberto Garcia Jorge Arce Acelino Frietas Ricky Hatton Bum Bum Rios Mike Alvarado Just to name a…

Comment by Ravens Fan on 10-12-2012

[QUOTE=!! Shawn;12594117]Thats not acceptable. Fighters from past eras shouldn't be judged by different criteria, they should be judged by the same. They all won their titles in fights vs other tough as nails opponents, none of them every bested a…

Comment by !! Shawn on 10-11-2012

[QUOTE=Ravens Fan;12594001]As far as comparing Gatti to the likes of Graziano and Basilio all three of them happened to be Italian and I compare little else. And the reason is simple. When both Graziano and Basilio retired there were eight…

Comment by !! Shawn on 10-11-2012

[QUOTE=crold1;12593823]Good post but worth pointing out Basilio and Zale would be HOFers without Robinson and Graziano. That was just the icing on the cake.[/QUOTE] For what? Losing to Gene Fullmer, Kid Gavilan, and basically every other big fight he ever…

Comment by Ravens Fan on 10-10-2012

[QUOTE=!! Shawn;12593517]There isn't a long list of fighters that encompass the ideas of blood and guts warriors than Gatti. He was actually more skilled then people give him credit for. Ive never been a big fan of his personally, nor…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (30)
Top Headlines Bryant Perrella-Yordenis Ugas on September 27, PBC on FS1 Giovanni De Carolis-Tyron Zeuge Rematch on November 5th Golovkin's Coach: Ward Beats Everyone at 175 - Except Kovalev! Vargas is Open To Facing Crawford After Stunning Pacquiao Sam Maxwell Turns Over, Joins MGM: Will Debut In October Golovkin Warns Saunders: My Goal is The WBO Belt, I Want it Next Anthony Crolla: I'll Have Jorge Linares Rematch in Las Vegas Williams-Patterson, Eubank Jr-Langford Confirmed For October 22 In Cardiff Derry Mathews Confident: I'll Dig Deep With Luke Campbell! Upton Brothers Leave Ricky Hatton Over "Turbulent Private Life" Dillian Whyte, Dereck Chisora Could Collide in December Smith Backs Froch: Kovalev is Best Pound For Pound Fighter! Amir Khan Says Land For Boxing Academy is Now in Dispute Team USA: Olympic Postmortem De La Hoya on Canelo-GGG: We Can't Afford To Wait Beyond 2017 Chocolatito: Cuadras Talks A lot, But I'll Prove it in The Ring! Golovkin: No Big Fights at 168, I Make 160 Easy - I'm Not Big 160 Juanma: Business Opportunity Made Me Return, Not Vazquez Morrison, Golub, Baranchyk, Peterkin Head To 9/23 ShoBox Robert Guerrero: I'm Ready For a World Title Shot Right Now! Photos: Gennady Golovkin, Roman Gonzalez Big Bear Media Day Saunders Still a Possibility for Canelo, Golden Boy Focused on Smith Jon Fernandez, Jose Roman Ink Pacts With Lou DiBella De La Hoya: Canelo a 154-Pounder, Will Fight Golovkin When Ready! Jarrell Miller's Promoter: He's Ready For Any World Champion Canelo: Margarito Fight Will NEVER Happen, He Should Retire Ramiro Carrillo, Achour Esho Return on October 1, UIC Pavilion Joshuanthony Ortiz, Edgardo Laboy Ink Pacts With Miguel Cotto Canelo Admits Move To 160 is Likely Next For His Career Mason Menard Puts a Target on The Back of Terry Flanagan Anthony Joshua-David Price Ruled Out For The Fall By Hearn James Kirkland Arrested Over Child Support Beef Photos: Anthony Crolla, Jorge Linares Go Face To Face Photos: Glowacki, Usyk - Go Face To Face at Open Workouts Jessie Vargas: "On November 5th I Will Shut The Critics Up!" Daniel Jacobs: Brook Just Too Small To Survive Against Golovkin Golovkin Laughs at Froch, Eubank: Those Clowns Won't Fight Me! J'Leon Love Will Face Dashon Johnson on September 16 Marlon Tapales vs. Paul Butler in The Works For The Fall De La Hoya: Canelo-Smith Will Have Up To 60,000 Fans at Venue!
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement