Advertisement
Advertisement

To Hell With the Official Verdict: Review, Ratings Update

By Cliff Rold

Adonis Stevenson validated his place as the Light Heavyweight Champion of the World on Saturday night.  The division was in a position where the winner could have been a man who just lost; instead, Stevenson one-upped the performances of Gabriel Campillo and Bernard Hopkins against Tavoris Cloud.

He outboxed him and beat him up.  No one had really seen Cloud hurt before Saturday; his toughness was a big asset.  Stevenson hurt him to the head and body, cut him over both eyes, and forced surrender.

That’s a good night in Canada.

It was a bad night in California.

Brian Vera, even after all manner of chicanery about the weight, outhustled and outfought Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. for most of their fight.  He won at least six, and probably more like eight rounds.  Chavez had spots.  Vera had rounds. 

The judges scored the spots.  They also scored what must have been wish fulfillment to think they saw Chavez win seven (judge Marty Denkin) or eight rounds (judge Gwen Adair) of his own.

It was a joke, the kind boxing fans are stuck with as part of their passion for the sport.  The fan base that remains in the US loves boxing despite its inherent silliness.  We’ll still live it after this.

But there is no reason to love Chavez.

These results, and the rest of the sports, are reflected in this BoxingScene divisional ratings update.

Ratings Changes

Heavyweight: WBC titlist Vitali Klitschko exits the ratings due to inactivity.  Dereck Chisora re-enters the top ten.

Light Heavyweight: Stevenson sits in the champion’s slot with nowhere to go but down and a whole lot of interesting options among his contenders.  Cloud slips in the ratings and is a shove away from exiting.

Middleweight: Chavez, who couldn’t even make Super Middleweight, exits the top ten at 160.  Vera, who is really a Middleweight, gets credit for what was a win in the ring against a former division titlist and moves up for what should be seen as a career best win streak at the moment.

Jr. Welter/Lightweight: Terrence Crawford, who was originally rated at 140 off his win over Prescott, was pointed out by a reader as wrongly placed given his current state.  That is amended here.  Crawford enters the top ten at Lightweight and Dierry Jean enters the top ten at 140.    

Report Card Picks 2013: 37-22

The full results of note and the total impact on the ratings are a click away.

>>>>>>Click Here To View BoxingScene's Full Divisional Ratings<<<<<<

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.   He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by BennyST on 10-02-2013

[QUOTE=PunchyPotorff;13800056]Some thoughts about Vera/Jr fight and others involving Jr..... If you go back and watch alot of Sr's fights, you'll see he was a dirty fighter in most of them. You'll see he laced, headbutted, threw low blows, you name…

Comment by giacomino on 10-01-2013

Agree with the decision on Vera/Jr. One question about the ratings: why is Shumenov still #7 a light heavy. He has not fought a warm body since the middle of 2010, he's not fought even a corpse in more than…

Comment by PunchyPotorff on 10-01-2013

Some thoughts about Vera/Jr fight and others involving Jr..... If you go back and watch alot of Sr's fights, you'll see he was a dirty fighter in most of them. You'll see he laced, headbutted, threw low blows, you name…

Comment by Ravens Fan on 10-01-2013

I was one that gave Vera eight rounds and when they read the scores I was elated and said to myself, "Imagine that they got this one right." Oh, how wrong I was to assume such a thing.

Comment by bojangles1987 on 10-01-2013

Boxing is the one sport where official results might as well not matter most the time.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (7)
Top Headlines Team USA: Olympic Postmortem De La Hoya on Canelo-GGG: We Can't Afford To Wait Beyond 2017 Chocolatito: Cuadras Talks A lot, But I'll Prove it in The Ring! Golovkin: No Big Fights at 168, I Make 160 Easy - I'm Not Big 160 Juanma: Business Opportunity Made Me Return, Not Vazquez Morrison, Golub, Baranchyk, Peterkin Head To 9/23 ShoBox Robert Guerrero: I'm Ready For a World Title Shot Right Now! Photos: Gennady Golovkin, Roman Gonzalez Big Bear Media Day Saunders Still a Possibility for Canelo, Golden Boy Focused on Smith Jon Fernandez, Jose Roman Ink Pacts With Lou DiBella De La Hoya: Canelo a 154-Pounder, Will Fight Golovkin When Ready! Jarrell Miller's Promoter: He's Ready For Any World Champion Canelo: Margarito Fight Will NEVER Happen, He Should Retire Ramiro Carrillo, Achour Esho Return on October 1, UIC Pavilion Joshuanthony Ortiz, Edgardo Laboy Ink Pacts With Miguel Cotto Canelo Admits Move To 160 is Likely Next For His Career Mason Menard Puts a Target on The Back of Terry Flanagan Anthony Joshua-David Price Ruled Out For The Fall By Hearn James Kirkland Arrested Over Child Support Beef Photos: Anthony Crolla, Jorge Linares Go Face To Face Photos: Glowacki, Usyk - Go Face To Face at Open Workouts Jessie Vargas: "On November 5th I Will Shut The Critics Up!" Daniel Jacobs: Brook Just Too Small To Survive Against Golovkin Golovkin Laughs at Froch, Eubank: Those Clowns Won't Fight Me! J'Leon Love Will Face Dashon Johnson on September 16 Marlon Tapales vs. Paul Butler in The Works For The Fall De La Hoya: Canelo-Smith Will Have Up To 60,000 Fans at Venue! Frampton: The UK Has 14 World Champions - Not All Are Legit! Gerard Carroll To Fight Twice In Eight Days De La Hoya: Canelo-Golovkin Won't Take 6 Years, But Not Now Daniel Geale vs. Renold Quinlan, Vacant IBO 168 Belt on 10/14 Tom Brown Reflects on The Lost Art of Building a Fighter Amir Khan Plans To Fight in January, May and December Caleb Plant Dominates De Angel in PBC on FS1 Main Event Jhonny Gonzalez vs. Hirotsugu Yamamoto Card Coming Together Canelo-Smith on Pace To Outdo Pacquiao, Says Golden Boy VP Video: Abel Sanchez on Brook, Andre Ward, 160 Landscape Video: Loeffler Talks Brook-Golovkin, Jacobs, Carl Froch, More Video: Gennady Golovkin Talks Kell Brook, Unification, More Video: Roman Gonzalez Talks Cuadras Clash, Training Camp
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement