Advertisement
Advertisement

To Hell With the Official Verdict: Review, Ratings Update

By Cliff Rold

Adonis Stevenson validated his place as the Light Heavyweight Champion of the World on Saturday night.  The division was in a position where the winner could have been a man who just lost; instead, Stevenson one-upped the performances of Gabriel Campillo and Bernard Hopkins against Tavoris Cloud.

He outboxed him and beat him up.  No one had really seen Cloud hurt before Saturday; his toughness was a big asset.  Stevenson hurt him to the head and body, cut him over both eyes, and forced surrender.

That’s a good night in Canada.

It was a bad night in California.

Brian Vera, even after all manner of chicanery about the weight, outhustled and outfought Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. for most of their fight.  He won at least six, and probably more like eight rounds.  Chavez had spots.  Vera had rounds. 

The judges scored the spots.  They also scored what must have been wish fulfillment to think they saw Chavez win seven (judge Marty Denkin) or eight rounds (judge Gwen Adair) of his own.

It was a joke, the kind boxing fans are stuck with as part of their passion for the sport.  The fan base that remains in the US loves boxing despite its inherent silliness.  We’ll still live it after this.

But there is no reason to love Chavez.

These results, and the rest of the sports, are reflected in this BoxingScene divisional ratings update.

Ratings Changes

Heavyweight: WBC titlist Vitali Klitschko exits the ratings due to inactivity.  Dereck Chisora re-enters the top ten.

Light Heavyweight: Stevenson sits in the champion’s slot with nowhere to go but down and a whole lot of interesting options among his contenders.  Cloud slips in the ratings and is a shove away from exiting.

Middleweight: Chavez, who couldn’t even make Super Middleweight, exits the top ten at 160.  Vera, who is really a Middleweight, gets credit for what was a win in the ring against a former division titlist and moves up for what should be seen as a career best win streak at the moment.

Jr. Welter/Lightweight: Terrence Crawford, who was originally rated at 140 off his win over Prescott, was pointed out by a reader as wrongly placed given his current state.  That is amended here.  Crawford enters the top ten at Lightweight and Dierry Jean enters the top ten at 140.    

Report Card Picks 2013: 37-22

The full results of note and the total impact on the ratings are a click away.

>>>>>>Click Here To View BoxingScene's Full Divisional Ratings<<<<<<

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member the Yahoo Pound for Pound voting panel, and the Boxing Writers Association of America.   He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by BennyST on 10-02-2013

[QUOTE=PunchyPotorff;13800056]Some thoughts about Vera/Jr fight and others involving Jr..... If you go back and watch alot of Sr's fights, you'll see he was a dirty fighter in most of them. You'll see he laced, headbutted, threw low blows, you name…

Comment by giacomino on 10-01-2013

Agree with the decision on Vera/Jr. One question about the ratings: why is Shumenov still #7 a light heavy. He has not fought a warm body since the middle of 2010, he's not fought even a corpse in more than…

Comment by PunchyPotorff on 10-01-2013

Some thoughts about Vera/Jr fight and others involving Jr..... If you go back and watch alot of Sr's fights, you'll see he was a dirty fighter in most of them. You'll see he laced, headbutted, threw low blows, you name…

Comment by Ravens Fan on 10-01-2013

I was one that gave Vera eight rounds and when they read the scores I was elated and said to myself, "Imagine that they got this one right." Oh, how wrong I was to assume such a thing.

Comment by bojangles1987 on 10-01-2013

Boxing is the one sport where official results might as well not matter most the time.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (7)
Top Headlines Photos: Marcos Maidana Resurfaces in The United States Crawford: Yuriorkis Gamboa is Still The Toughest Fight I've Had Terence Crawford: Manny Pacquiao Must Fight Me at 140! Roach Likes The Idea of Pacquiao vs. Crawford, at 140-Pounds Crawford Trainer: We Weren't on Roach's Level? Freddie Who? Crawford: I Hurt Postol With Every Solid Shot That Connected Terence Crawford Drops, Dominates Postol To Unify Titles Crawford vs. Postol LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Oscar Valdez Crushes Rueda in Two, Wins WBO Title Jose Benavidez Decisions Francisco Santana in Bruising Bout Gvozdyk Gets Off The Floor To Stop Karpency in Six Maidana Breaks Down Maysonet In Six Rounds Ryota Murata Demolishes Comanche Boy in One Round Roach Admits Confusion in Golovkin-Ward Comments Fabian Maidana Aims To Emerge From Marcos' Shadow Lenny Zappavigna Stops Ik Yang in Six Rounds Video: Jose Benavidez Pumped For Santana Showdown Salido: They Have To Pay Me A lot For Lomachenko, Vargas! Crawford vs. Postol LIVE Results From Las Vegas Roach: Brook Has NO Shot To Beat Gennady Golovkin Video: David Benavidez Discusses His Future, Return, More Video: Francisco Santana Ready For War With Benavidez Crawford Not Concerned About Postol’s Height, Reach Edge Wilder, Arreola Test Clean For All Banned Substances Eleider Alvarez-Robert Berridge Set For PBC Card Video: Viktor Postol Ready To Put on a Show With Crawford Roach: I Want Pacquiao To Fight at Least Two More Times Video: Oleksandr Gvozdyk on PPV Fight, The Future, More Video: Oscar Valdez Ready For Statement Title Win With Rueda Video: Freddie Roach on Pacquiao, Floyd Mayweather, More Michael Perez vs. Petr Petrov WBA Eliminator is Ordered Postol: Of Course I Want To Beat Terence Crawford By Knockout Warren: Smith Will Be Treated as World Star After Beating Canelo Crawford's Trainer: Postol is Cashing Out, He Wanted a Check Francisco Santana on Benavidez, leans to Crawford over Postol Daily Bread Mailbag: Ward-Kovalev, GGG-Brook, Broner, More Video: Matias Rueda Confident of Shocking Oscar Valdez Video: Crawford's Trainer Media Interview - Two Parter Tommy Coyle Aims To Make History in Leeds Showdown Crawford Senses Fear: Postol Refused To Look Me in The Eyes
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement